The Major League Soccer play-in games delivered some terrific drama on Thursday, but now it's time to turn our attention to the main event with my MLS moneyline picks for the opening matches of the Round of 16 of the 2026 MLS Cup playoffs.
Saturday sees the MLS Cup playoffs kick into full gear with three matches on the docket. This round is a best-of-three in a home/away/home format, with tied matches going straight to penalties.
Getting any kind of result as an away side becomes crucial, and I'm picking a pair of clubs to do just that.
MLS moneyline picks for Nov. 21-24
| Game | Pick |
|---|---|
| Draw 25% | |
| Draw 19% | |
Probabilities courtesy of Kalshi, one of the best prediction market apps. Update the probabilities before publishing.
Start trading with Kalshi today!
Sign up now using our exclusive Kalshi promo code 'MAX60' and trade $25 on any event contracts to get $60.
*Eligible U.S. locations only

Expert MLS moneyline picks
New England Revolution vs Philadelphia Union pick: Draw
Saturday, Nov. 21 | 2 p.m.
Both teams enter the playoffs on a bit of a slump, although Philly did get a win to end their regular season. That said, I see little between these sides and would back the draw to 29%.
New England did win both meetings 2-1 this season, but they won't enjoy their usual playoff weather advantage as temperatures will be in the mid-60s. This should be a very tight, entertaining affair that comes down to spot kicks.
FC Dallas vs Portland Timbers pick: Dallas
Saturday, Nov. 21 | 4 p.m.
I have Dallas winning this match up to 55% and love getting them at 51%.
Portland comes in winning their last four to make the playoffs, but did so by beating three slumping sides in St. Louis, Houston, and Austin.
Dallas are unbeaten at home vs. Portland in seven straight, winning six of those matches. They were also tremendous at home this season, while Portland were 4-3-10 away from home.
Petar Musa will be the difference here as he terrorizes Portland yet again.
Inter Miami CF vs Columbus Crew pick: Draw
Saturday, Nov. 21 | 6 p.m.
I'm backing the draw, which is a real bargain seeing as I have it fairly priced at 25%
Yes, Inter Miami has Lionel Messi. But unless he's suddenly learned to play defense, there is no justifying Miami being favored at 60% probability.
Not at home, where they won just six of 17 matches with nine draws. And certainly not with a back line that has conceded multiple goals in four straight matches.
The Crew are lethal on the break, and will use that to force penalty kicks with their second South Beach draw this year.
Nashville SC vs FC Cincinnati pick: Nashville
Sunday, Nov. 22 | 4 p.m.
Nashville is the correct side here — but not playable at this price.
FC Cincinnati somehow escaped Orlando with a 3-1 win despite a 3.41-1.79 xG disadvantage.
Now on short rest, they have to take on the best team in the league. And unlike Orlando, Nashville doesn't waste chances. In fact, they scored 14 more goals than expected this season.
Take the home side, but skip the juice and look instead at the spread or combine them with another play.
Chicago Fire vs Charlotte FC pick: Chicago Fire
Sunday, Nov. 22 | 6:30 p.m.
I'm holding my nose as I drink the juice here, but do not go past 60%.
Tim Ream's likely absence in defense is a brutal blow for Charlotte, who not only rely on his leadership but his distribution at the back.
The Fire have won four straight against the visitors, are the more well-rounded side, and have a proven clutch performer in Robert Lewandowski. They're also far healthier, which matters this time of year.
St. Louis CITY SC vs LAFC pick: St. Louis CITY SC
Monday, Nov. 23 | 8 p.m.
At just 42% probability, there's value on the home side to win and I'm backing them to 46%.
LAFC won just two of their last 15 matches in the league, both of which came at home. They took just two points from their last five away matches, including a humiliating 3-1 defeat to Sporting KC.
St. Louis fell off hard after their US Open Cup run, but their win away at Houston to end the season was a positive note. Combine their home-field advantage with the injuries to LAFC's Timothy Tillman, Aaron Long, and Hugo Lloris, and they're worth backing at this number.
San Jose Earthquakes vs Houston Dynamo pick: San Jose Earthquakes
Tuesday, Nov. 24 | 10 p.m.
I'm on San Jose here up to 50%.
Houston has won just once in their last 10 matches, and the goals have dried up as they've scored just twice in their last four outings.
San Jose are unbeaten at home in six, including a 1-0 win over Houston in September. Timo Werner and Niko Tsakiris are both finally healthy together, and that will be the difference here.
- Moneyline picks: 168-240, +4.55 units
Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.






