2025 Conn Smythe Trophy Odds: Sam Bennett Awarded Playoff MVP

Western Conference juggernauts dominated the Conn Smythe odds for the majority of the playoffs, but it's Sam Bennett who got the last laugh.

Kyle LaRusic - Betting Analyst at Covers.com
Kyle LaRusic • Betting Analyst
Jun 18, 2025 • 09:44 ET • 3 min read
Sam Bennett Florida Panthers NHL
Photo By - Imagn Images. Sam Bennett getting handed the Conn Smythe Trophy.

After scoring 15 goals in the postseason, Sam Bennett was rightfully rewarded with the 2025 Conn Smythe Trophy.

Bennett was one of six Florida forwards with 20+ points, but Bennett's tenacity and timely scoring gave him the nod above his teammates.

🏆 2025 Conn Smythe Trophy odds

Player Position Sports Interaction
Stars Sam Bennett Forward -220
Stars Brad Marchand  Forward +375
Oilers Leon Draisaitl Forward +800
Oilers Connor McDavid Forward +900
Stars Sergei Bobrovsky Goaltender +12500
Stars Matthew Tkachuk Forward +25000
Stars Sam Reinhart Forward +25000
Stars Carter Verhaeghe Forward +25000
Stars Aleksander Barkov Forward +27500

Conn Smythe trophy opening odds

  • Connor Hellebuyck, Jets: +1500
  • Connor McDavid, Oilers: +1300
  • Sebastian Aho, Hurricanes: +1500
  • Jack Eichel, Golden Knights: +1600
  • Anthony Stolarz, Maple Leafs: +1800
  • Auston Matthews, Maple Leafs: +1800
  • Nathan MacKinnon, Avalanche: +1800
  • Adrian Kempe, Kings: +2000
  • Aleksander Barkov, Panthers: +2000
  • Alex Ovechkin, Capitals: +2000
  • Darcy Kuemper, Kings: +2000
  • Matthew Tkachuk, Panthers: +2000
  • Mitch Marner, Maple Leafs: +2000
  • Seth Jarvis, Hurricanes: +2000
  • Leon Draisaitl, Oilers: +2200
  • Cale Makar, Avalanche: +2500
  • Sergei Bobrovsky, Panthers: +3000

2025 Vezina Trophy and Hart Trophy winner Connor Hellebuyck opened as the betting favorite to add the Conn Smythe to his trophy case.

📊 Conn Smythe Trophy betting splits

Highest ticket percentage:
•    Connor McDavid 8.7%
•    Mikko Rantanen 7.1%
•    Sergei Bobrovsky 6.2%

Highest handle percentage:
•   Mikko Rantanen 13.2%
•   Frederik Andersen 8.8%
•   Connor McDavid 8.5%

Biggest liabilities:
•    Mikko Rantanen
•    Connor McDavid
•    Brad Marchand

All data courtesy of BetMGM.

Sam Bennett was nowhere to be found in the betting slips, making for a happy ending for the books — and even happier ending for those who bet on him.


Covers NHL Playoff tools

📈 Conn Smythe Trophy trends

  • There have only been five players to win the Conn Smythe without winning the Stanley Cup.
  • Skaters have won the Conn Smythe over a goalie 74% of the time.
  • There have been seven repeat winners of the Conn Smythe since its establishment.
  • Only one player has won the Conn Smythe more than twice. Patrick Roy won it three times.

📜 Conn Smythe Trophy history

A quick look at recent NHL Conn Smythe Trophy winners and the teams they played for.

Season Player Team
2024-25 Sam Bennett Oilers Florida Panthers
2023-24 Connor McDavid Oilers Edmonton Oilers
2022-23 Jonathan Marchessault Golden Knights Vegas Golden Knights
2021-22 Cale Makar Avalanche Colorado Avalanche
2020-21 Andrei Vasilevskiy Lightning Tampa Bay Lightning
2019-20 Victor Hedman Lightning Tampa Bay Lightning
2018-19 Ryan O'Reilly Blues St. Louis Blues
2017-18 Alex Ovechkin Capitals Washington Capitals
2016-17 Sidney Crosby Penguins Pittsburgh Penguins
2015-16 Sidney Crosby Penguins Pittsburgh Penguins
2014-15 Duncan Keith Blackhawks Chicago Blackhawks
2013-14 Justin Williams Kings Los Angeles Kings
2012-13 Patrick Kane Blackhawks Chicago Blackhawks
2011-12 Jonathan Quick Kings Los Angeles Kings
2010-11 Tim Thomas Bruins Boston Bruins
2009-10 Jonathan Toews Blackhawks Chicago Blackhawks
2008-09 Evgeni Malkin Penguins Pittsburgh Penguins
2007-08 Henrik Zetterberg Red Wings Detroit Red Wings
2006-07 Scott Niedermayer Ducks Anaheim Ducks
2005-06 Cam Ward Hurricanes Carolina Hurricanes
2003-04 Brad Richards Lightning Tampa Bay Lightning

Understanding Conn Smythe Trophy odds

Sportsbooks will post Conn Smythe Trophy odds as early as the beginning of the playoffs. These NHL futures are constantly adjusted throughout the postseason depending on how well players perform as well as their team success. Sportsbooks will also adjust the NHL awards odds based on handle and liability to certain players.

Conn Smythe Trophy odds will usually look like this:

  • Nathan MacKinnon +290

This means that on a $100 bet, you'll stand to win $290 if MacKinnon takes home the Conn Smythe Trophy. If it's close to the end of the Stanley Cup playoffs and a player has stood out as the obvious MVP of the series they might have a minus sign (-) ahead of their odds like this: 

  • Connor McDavid -175

This means that if you bet on McDavid to win the Conn Smythe Trophy, you would have needed to bet $175 to profit $100.

All of the odds listed above are in American format, but if you prefer decimal or fractional odds, simply plug them into our odds converter tool.

Conn Smythe Trophy Odds FAQs

Pages related to this topic

Kyle LaRusic - Covers
Betting Analyst

Kyle LaRusic joined Covers in 2020 with a Holland College diploma in Journalism and a Mount Saint Vincent Degree in Public Relations. Stints at Amherst News and the Cape Breton Post helped sharpen his skills in a newsroom setting, while working for MSVU and Dalhousie’s athletic departments landed Kyle in his comfort zone.

Kyle has been an avid bettor for over five years, starting with just one Sports Interaction account before discovering both the beauty and importance of price shopping. bet365 and Pinnacle are his go to books, but accounts at 10+ sportsbooks give him an array of options. “Rusty” will bet on anything under the sun as long as there’s value and good reasoning behind it, but NHL and NFL are his two favorite leagues to watch and wager on — especially with friends.

Kyle’s biggest tip for any bettor is simple: gamble responsibly. Only bet what you’re willing to lose and make sure to install a proper bankroll method to keep track of your ROI. If you’re still dwelling on the amount you lost the next day, it’s time to decrease your spending.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo