Is It Chalked? Why NFL Favorites' Costly Run Is Business as Usual for Sportsbooks, Prediction Markets

Geoff Zochodne - Sports Betting Journalist at Covers.com
Geoff Zochodne • Senior News Analyst 15+ years betting experience
Updated: Nov 20, 2026 , 04:46 PM ET • 5 min read

While a couple of brutal weeks may have stung the industry, it also means, among other things, that bettors and traders have a bit more money to play with heading into Thanksgiving.

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen (17) celebrates after scoring a touchdown during the second half against the New York Jets at MetLife Stadium. Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images
Photo By - Reuters Connect. Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen (17) celebrates after scoring a touchdown during the second half against the New York Jets at MetLife Stadium. Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

The moneyline parlay has been a real weapon over the past few weeks - a double-edged sword, in fact.

Covers Icon
Key Takeaways
  • NFL favorites have dominated recent weeks, delivering big wins for bettors and costly losses for sportsbooks and prediction market makers.
  • Some analysts say consecutive weeks of unfavorable results could weigh on publicly traded sportsbook operators' earnings.
  • Sportsbooks and market makers may be adjusting their prices but generally view the streak as a normal part of the NFL season.

NFL favorites have been winning and covering at a relatively high rate recently. This has benefited bettors and traders who back those teams and punished online sportsbooks and prediction market makers exposed to those outcomes.

Thursday night’s Texans-Colts was yet another example. Houston was favored by 12.5 points and wound up winning and covering comfortably against an Indianapolis team that is blowing it up piece by piece. 

So it’s been a chalky stretch of NFL football. According to Covers trends data, NFL favorites are 46-12 straight up over the past month and 38-20 against the spread.

Some stock analysts have already flagged recent game outcomes as a potential concern ahead of online sports betting companies' fourth-quarter earnings releases.

Citizens analysts said in a note to clients Thursday that “early November trends are also shaping up to be less than ideal,” including a Week 9 in which favorites went 14-1 straight up and 11-4 against the spread. 

“Week 10 did not produce materially better results, indicating another soft week and adding to what is already shaping up to be a challenging quarter for sports betting,” they added. 

The rest of Week 11 could bring more of the same, with five games still to come with point spreads of a touchdown or more. So what's a bookmaker or market maker to do? 

The short answer may be: Don’t panic. Keep calm and book/quote on.

Eventually, the results could go your way - or against you, if you're a bettor. It also doesn’t hurt to have people with a bit more money to play with heading into Thanksgiving, either. The holidays will offer ample opportunity for the industry to win that money back.

“It's always a give-and-take business,” said Tom Gable, the director of race and sports at the Borgata in Atlantic City. “You want people to win at least some of the time, and you don't want to just crush bettors by any means. You need to keep the business sustainable, so you have weeks like that, and that keeps the business sustainable.”

You have to budget for a few brutal weeks every season, Gable said, and the last two weeks have been that. Week 9 was the worst Sunday of the season thus far for the Borgata, he noted.

You're crushing it

It's been an improbable stretch of success for NFL favorites, too.

Bernard Marantelli, founder and CEO of White Swan Data and White Swan Predicts (a major PM market maker), posted on LinkedIn this week that the industry got “crushed” again in Week 10.

It was, however, a pretty unlikely crushing.

Marantelli said his team ran each week's Kalshi pre-match NFL parlays through its model 50,000 times using closing prices. It found that Week 9 results were a “1-in-145 week,” or something that happens around once every eight NFL seasons. 

Week 10 was a 1-in-12 kind of week. “Bad, but the kind that comes less than twice a season,” Marantelli wrote.

Still, back-to-back weeks like that will hurt. And now comes Week 11, where you’ve got multiple double-digit favorites. It may not be ideal if you’re trying to avoid another moneyline tsunami.

Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

The numbers game

There could be room for a bit of tweaking, particularly to team power ratings. So don't be surprised if your moneyline parlay this week offers a much smaller payout than in previous weeks.

“We've had a major adjustment in the market,” Circa Sports CEO Derek Stevens noted on VSiN on Thursday.

Stevens noted there are five double-digit favorites this week, including last night’s game. 

“It’s kind of hard to throw those into a parlay,” he said.

If you were to combine the four remaining double-digit favorites into a parlay right now, you’d get a price of around -200, which may not be enticing enough for casual bettors. At the very least, they’d have to risk more to win more, if they win at all. 

And who knows? Maybe the Dolphins have a miracle in them against the Bills. But, again, there’s no panic setting in. 

Jeff Benson, director of operations for race and sportsbook at Circa, said it has been a “notable run” for NFL favorites, especially given how efficient the betting markets can be. Even so, it’s part of the game. 

“While these stretches always attract attention, we generally view them as part of the normal ebb and flow of an NFL season rather than something that's likely to persist long term,” Benson said in an email. 

And for a sportsbook, “the impact really depends on where the money is,” Benson added. 

“Favorites covering tends to be better for bettors when they're aligned with public action, but each week's results are ultimately driven by the specific teams and wagering patterns involved,” he wrote. 

There are, for example, sharper bettors who still see a pricey moneyline as good value. Gable pointed to the Bears this week, who opened at the Borgata at around -450 before getting bet to -650 by respected money.

Gable also said Borgata can get more aggressive with its moneylines to attract bets on either side of a game. But even then, Borgata isn’t ratcheting up the price of favorites too much. 

It could, though. That's because bettors placing large moneyline parlays may not be particularly concerned about the odds they're getting, anyway.

“For the most part, the people who are playing those moneyline favorite parlays every week aren't necessarily price conscious to begin with,” Gable said. 

Pages related to this topic

Geoff Zochodne, Covers Sports Betting Journalist
Senior News Analyst

Geoff has been writing about the legalization and regulation of sports betting in Canada and the United States for more than four years. His work has included coverage of launches in New York, Ohio, and Ontario, numerous court proceedings, and the decriminalization of single-game wagering by Canadian lawmakers. As an expert on the growing online gambling industry in North America, Geoff has appeared on and been cited by publications and networks such as Axios, TSN Radio, and VSiN. Prior to joining Covers, he spent 10 years as a journalist reporting on business and politics, including a stint at the Ontario legislature. More recently, Geoff’s work has focused on the pending launch of a competitive iGaming market in Alberta, the evolution of major companies within the gambling industry, and efforts by U.S. state regulators to rein in offshore activity and college player prop betting.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo