Is This Trade Fair?

Standard scoring league. 6pt passing TDs Start 1 QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, & 1 Flex.
Guy wants to trade Vick & Wells for Blount, Orton, & McNabb.

The guy trading Vick & Blount has Freeman who he would start. Since he has Freeman why would he want to add Orton & McNabb so bad? What do they really bring to the deal for him? So then is Blount going to be that much better than Wells this year?

I would take Vick and Wells in this one hands down.  Vick is better then any those 2 qb's and who even needs to qb's.
As for wells, he will be a FT back so to me he has much more value.  Blount.  Blount cannot catch so he will not be used in passing game.

I think it's hugely in the favor of the guy getting Vick and Wells so I don't think it's fair at all. I'd jump on it. 

person getting Vick/Wells wins this hands down.

League busting trade for sure.

I would want to get Vick and Wells if I had to be on one side of this deal.

im a buckeye ...love wells but he couldnt stay healthy in college and he cant stay heathly in the pros

Bullshit trade vetoed.
I've talked to 7 league members not involved in the trade and 6 think it's a joke. The other person doesn't know shit so doesn't have an opinion lol.

Appreciate the thoughts.

Totally lopsided toward the Vick side.  I don't even think that trade would be fair if Wells was not involved.

Did either player have any other plans to trade some of these players after this trade?

I think Blount still has to prove something to me, some guys get so hyped up its crazy.

take vick

that has got to be a BS trade...Totally 1 sided

Instead of giving up a blount type of player, it would be more like a top 5 or 6 rb like Felix Jones or a charles even,....

Felix Jones is a top 5 or 6 RB?

We ended up letting Vick (2nd rd) for Blount (3rd rd) & Orton (9th rd) go through. I like the Vick side of it better but it's probably close enough.

Next year I'm banning all preseason transactions in my leagues so I won't have to worry about any stupid nonsense like this.
Why the hell does someone draft a player just to trade them immediately after the draft

Getting a little ahead of yourself here. How about he actually does something in the regular season before we annoint him fantasy star?

I like the vick side of things