Final May 3
COL 2 -165 o5.5
DAL 4 +140 u5.5
New York 6th Metropolitan35-35-9-3
Pittsburgh 7th Metropolitan34-36-6-6

Islanders vs Penguins Picks & Props

PPG Paints Arena

NYI vs PIT Covers Picks

View all Covers Picks

Covers Picks

Covers picks are made by our in-house sports betting experts, using analysis to guide their predictions and provide the best picks.

There are no Covers Picks for this match up at the moment. Visit our Picks page to see all Covers picks.

NYI vs PIT Consensus Picks

View all Consensus Picks

Consensus Picks

Our consensus picks show you what percentage of the public is betting on, you'll need to decide whether you want to bet with or against the public.

Moneyline

71% picking Pittsburgh

29%
71%

Total PicksNYI 166, PIT 405

Moneyline
NYI
PIT
Moneyline

NYI vs PIT Props

Props
Player
Prop
Season Avg.
Best Odds

Bryan Rust Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

B. Rust
right wing RW • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.44
Best Odds
Over
+210
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.44
Best Odds
Over
+210

Scott Perunovich Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

S. Perunovich
defense D • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.06
Best Odds
Over
+700
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.06
Best Odds
Over
+700

Pierre Engvall Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

P. Engvall
left wing LW • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.13
Best Odds
Over
+450
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.13
Best Odds
Over
+450

Blake Lizotte Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

B. Lizotte
center C • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.19
Best Odds
Over
+450
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.19
Best Odds
Over
+450

Kevin Hayes Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

K. Hayes
right wing RW • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.20
Best Odds
Over
+420
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.20
Best Odds
Over
+420

Adam Boqvist Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

A. Boqvist
defense D • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.11
Best Odds
Over
+700
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.11
Best Odds
Over
+700

Noel Acciari Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

N. Acciari
center C • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.06
Best Odds
Over
+700
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.06
Best Odds
Over
+700

Conor Timmins Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

C. Timmins
defense D • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.04
Best Odds
Over
+900
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.04
Best Odds
Over
+900

Kyle Palmieri Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

K. Palmieri
right wing RW • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.29
Best Odds
Over
+230
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.29
Best Odds
Over
+230

Scott Mayfield Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

S. Mayfield
defense D • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.05
Best Odds
Over
+1300
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.05
Best Odds
Over
+1300

Matt Grzelcyk Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

M. Grzelcyk
defense D • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.01
Best Odds
Over
+700
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.01
Best Odds
Over
+700

Kris Letang Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

K. Letang
defense D • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.12
Best Odds
Over
+700
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.12
Best Odds
Over
+700

Anders Lee Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

A. Lee
left wing LW • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.35
Best Odds
Over
+195
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.35
Best Odds
Over
+195

Connor Dewar Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

C. Dewar
center C • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.08
Best Odds
Over
+600
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.08
Best Odds
Over
+600

Ryan Graves Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

R. Graves
defense D • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.02
Best Odds
Over
+1100
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.02
Best Odds
Over
+1100

Casey Cizikas Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

C. Cizikas
center C • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.09
Best Odds
Over
+540
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.09
Best Odds
Over
+540

Kyle MacLean Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

K. MacLean
center C • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.05
Best Odds
Over
+700
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.05
Best Odds
Over
+700

Sidney Crosby Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

S. Crosby
center C • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.41
Best Odds
Over
+160
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.41
Best Odds
Over
+160

Tony DeAngelo Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

T. DeAngelo
defense D • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.11
Best Odds
Over
+700
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.11
Best Odds
Over
+700

Maxim Tsyplakov Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

M. Tsyplakov
right wing RW • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.13
Best Odds
Over
+350
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.13
Best Odds
Over
+350

Noah Dobson Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

N. Dobson
defense D • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.14
Best Odds
Over
+450
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.14
Best Odds
Over
+450

Erik Karlsson Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

E. Karlsson
defense D • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.13
Best Odds
Over
+550
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.13
Best Odds
Over
+550

Grant Hutton Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

G. Hutton
defense D • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.00
Best Odds
Over
+1050
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.00
Best Odds
Over
+1050

Danton Heinen Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

D. Heinen
left wing LW • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.11
Best Odds
Over
+360
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.11
Best Odds
Over
+360

Bo Horvat Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

B. Horvat
center C • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.35
Best Odds
Over
+188
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.35
Best Odds
Over
+188

Mike Reilly Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

M. Reilly
defense D • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.00
Best Odds
Over
+750
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.00
Best Odds
Over
+750

Evgeni Malkin Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

E. Malkin
center C • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.24
Best Odds
Over
+275
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.24
Best Odds
Over
+275

Alexander Romanov Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

A. Romanov
defense D • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.06
Best Odds
Over
+1050
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.06
Best Odds
Over
+1050

Adam Pelech Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

A. Pelech
defense D • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.00
Best Odds
Over
+750
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.00
Best Odds
Over
+750

Anthony Duclair Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

A. Duclair
left wing LW • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.16
Best Odds
Over
+285
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.16
Best Odds
Over
+285

Philip Tomasino Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

P. Tomasino
center C • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.18
Best Odds
Over
+360
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.18
Best Odds
Over
+360

Jean-Gabriel Pageau Goals Scored Props • NY Islanders

J. Pageau
center C • NY Islanders
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.18
Best Odds
Over
+350
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.18
Best Odds
Over
+350

Vladislav Kolyachonok Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

V. Kolyachonok
defense D • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.06
Best Odds
Over
+1100
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.06
Best Odds
Over
+1100

Rickard Rakell Goals Scored Props • Pittsburgh

R. Rakell
right wing RW • Pittsburgh
Prop
0.5
Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.43
Best Odds
Over
+165
Prop
0.5 Goals Scored
Season Avg.
0.43
Best Odds
Over
+165

How is Value calculated?

Our value picks are based on the Expected Value (EV) of placing the bet, using our projections and the current odds price:

0-2 Stars: Negative to Even EV
3-4 Stars: Positive EV
5 Stars: Highest EV

NYI vs PIT Preview

Last Meeting ( Dec 29, 2024 ) NY Islanders 2, Pittsburgh 3

Impressive third periods by the Pittsburgh Penguins and New York Islanders on Saturday and Sunday ensured they'd each still remain on the fringes of the Eastern Conference wildcard race for at least another game.

NYI vs PIT Top User Picks

View all Top User Picks

User Picks

Our user picks are made by you, our valued users - we highlight the best user picks, sharing the users who are on a hot streak.

There are no User Picks for this match up at the moment. Visit our Team Leaders page to see all User picks.

Pages Related to This Topic

Some of our content has moved

Records, stats, injuries can be found in the Stats tab. Preview, props can be found in the Picks Tab.