Rangers vs Maple Leafs Picks and Predictions: Leafs Should Dominate Behind Matthews' Return

Toronto enters this matchup looking to take advantage of its great goaltending and will aim to capitalize on its offensive chances against a leaky Rangers defense, especially with the return of Auston Matthews. Find out more in our Rangers vs Leafs picks.

Last Updated: Oct 18, 2021 2:36 PM ET Read Time: 4 min
Auston Matthews Toronto Maple Leafs NHL
Photo By - USA TODAY Sports

The New York Rangers kicked off a four-game road trip with their first win of the season Saturday night, but will take a much larger step up in competition Monday night in visiting Scotiabank Arena to face the Toronto Maple Leafs.

Despite being without star Auston Matthews, the Leafs have gotten off to a 2-1 start and are massive NHL betting favorites at home tonight... possibly because AM34 is returning?

Here are our best free NHL picks and predictions for Rangers vs. Maple Leafs on Monday, October 18, with puck drop set for 7:00 p.m. ET.

Rangers vs Maple Leafs odds

Odds via the Covers Line, an average comprised of odds from multiple sportsbooks.

Compare NHL odds before betting to ensure you get the best numberr
and view the full line movement for this game.

Rangers vs Maple Leafs picks

Picks made on 10/17/2021 at 2:30 p.m. ET.
Click on each pick to jump to the full analysis.

Best NHL bonuses

If you're signing up for a new sportsbook for 2021-22 NHL season, here are two of the best welcome bonuses available:

USA: Maple Leafs shutout win vs Rangers BOOSTED to +1,000 at Fanduel. Claim Now

Canada: Sign up with Sports Interaction and get up to $500 in free bets. Claim Now

Rangers vs Maple Leafs game info

Location: Scotiabank Arena, Toronto, ON
Date: Monday, October 18, 2021
Puck drop: 7:00 p.m. ET
TV: Sportsnet, MSG

Rangers vs Maple Leafs betting preview


Rangers: Kaapo Kakko RW (Out), Ryan Strome C (Out).
Maple Leafs: Auston Matthews C (Probable), Jake Muzzin D (Questionable), Petr Mrazek G (Out), Ilya Mikheyev RW (Out).
Find our latest NHL injury reports.

Rangers vs Maple Leafs head-to-head record (since 2018)

Rangers: 4-2, 22 goals for.
Maple Leafs: 2-2-2, 20 goals for.

Betting trend to know

The Under is 15-5-3 in New York's last 23 games as a road underdog. Find more NHL betting trends for Rangers vs. Maple Leafs.

Rangers vs Maple Leafs picks and predictions

Despite being without the reigning Rocket Richard Trophy winner (and fifth-highest scorer in the NHL last season) — and the league's No. 4 point scorer (Mitch Marner) having one assist through three games — Toronto has gotten off to a 2-1 start, thanks to some outstanding goaltending and an offense that's still generating plenty of chances.

After playing outstanding hockey as Freddie Andersen's backup last season, Jack Campbell has been elevated into the No. 1 spot this year and has shined through two games. The 11th-overall pick in 2010, Campbell struggled throughout his career but posted a 2.15 goals-against average and .921 save percentage in 22 games last season and this year he has a 0.86 GAA and .968 SV%  — with nearly four Goals Saved Above Average already.

He won't make it easy on a Rangers team that is shooting just 5.4 percent at even strength, has the eighth-worst Fenwick For Percentage at 5-v-5, and seventh-lowest expected goals for (2.06) per 60 minutes of 5-v-5 action. Campbell's play has also provided a reliable backbone for an offense that is getting good chances — generating 12.06 high-danger chances per 60 minutes (second in the NHL) — and should have their best sniper back.

Auston Matthews sat out the first three games recovering from wrist surgery, but head coach Sheldon Keefe said he 'fully expects' Matthews to make his debut Monday night — terrible news for a Rangers team that has struggled to keep opponents from getting good shots on net.

New York has given up a whopping 37 shots from inside the "home plate" (considered the top-quality shooting area that spans directly in from the front of the net to the top of the face circles and between the faceoff dots), including eight of their nine goals against. That number would be even higher if not for the outstanding play of Igor Shesterkin, who's been phenomenal through two games — but it may not matter Monday night.

Both Montreal and Dallas were in the bottom-third of the NHL in scoring and shooting percentage the past two seasons, while the one good offense New York has faced — the Capitals (Top 5 each of last two years) — lit up the Blueshirts for five goals, including three on the power play (and a shorthanded goal as well).

Toronto's offense (second in GF in 19/20, sixth in 20/21) is much closer to Washington than New York's other opponents — especially with Matthews back and reunited with Marner.

Add in that New York is also missing two of its top-six forwards (Kaapo Kakko and Ryan Strome) and with how the Rangers are playing it will take another herculean effort from Shesterkin to even keep this close.

And even that might not be enough.

The Under is 5-0-1 through six combined games for Toronto and New York this season, with no singular team topping even three goals aside from Washington potting five against the Blueshirts.

While that was an awful all-around performance by New York, who got wholeheartedly dominated in the final 40 minutes after a strong first period, it wasn't helped by a terrible effort from backup goalie Alexandar Georgiev. Having Shesterkin between the pipes is a big improvement for the Rangers, and will help keep Toronto from putting up a terribly crooked number — even with Matthews returning.

What's really driving this Under bet, however, is us struggling to see how the Rangers, who have five non-empty-net goals through three games, will score much against a Toronto team that has a red-hot goalie in Campbell and is much better in puck possession and controlling the play. 

NHL parlays

Did you know that if you parlayed today’s NHL Rangers vs. Maple Leafs picks, you could win $33.91 on a $10 bet?

Use our NHL parlay calculator to create your own parlays and see their potential payouts.

Where can I bet on the NHL?

You can bet on NHL odds at every online and casino sportsbook, including NHL moneylines, puck lines, Over/Under totals, and a ton of NHL prop odds. Head over to our best sportsbooks for NHL betting in your area.

Popular Content

Covers 25 Years Logo Established in 1995,
Covers is the world
leader in sports
betting information.
Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo