Eagles vs Bills Props & Best Bets for Week 17

With the rushing title race heating up, expect James Cook to shine and make his case as the frontrunner as he headlines our top Eagles vs. Bills player prop picks.

Jeremy Jones - Contributor at Covers
Jeremy Jones • Betting Analyst
Dec 27, 2025 • 15:43 ET • 4 min read
James Cook Buffalo Bills NFL
Photo By - Imagn Images. Buffalo Bills running back James Cook III (4) runs with the ball.

The premier game of Sunday afternoon features two Super Bowl hopefuls when the 10-5 Philadelphia Eagles travel to northern New York to take on the 11-4 Buffalo Bills.

There are several matchup advantages for both teams that we can exploit to find great value in a few player props.

Here are my top three NFL player prop picks for the Eagles vs Bills on Sunday, December 28.

Eagles vs Bills props

Player Pick FanDuel
Bills Josh Allen Over 6.5 rush attempts -106
Eagles Dallas Goedert Under 3.5 receptions -114
Bills James Cook Longest rush Over 15.5 yards -114
Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

Prop bet #1: Josh Allen Over 6.5 rush attempts

-106 at FanDuel

Josh Allen has never been afraid to put his body on the line in big games and take off running when needed. The Buffalo Bills need a win to stay alive in the AFC East race and for seeding overall. He should find plenty of rushing opportunities against this Philadelphia Eagles defense.

The Eagles have the seventh ranked passing defense in yards allowed but rank 21st in rushing yards allowed. They also rank 28th in the NFL in defending quarterback scrambles. And nobody scrambles quite like Josh Allen does in key situations.

Allen has at least seven rush attempts in each of the last four games for the Bills and seven times overall this season. The last time the Eagles faced a scrambling quarterback, they allowed 10 rush attempts to Justin Herbert.

There is also the chance we get kneel downs from Allen at the end of either half, so I love his attempts Over rather than his yardage Over.

Prop bet #2: Dallas Goedert Under 3.5 receptions

-114 at FanDuel

Dallas Goedert has feasted this season in the play action passing game for the Eagles. He has accounted for a team-high 34.7% target share on play action-passes this season and has totaled twice as many receptions as any other Eagles receiver off play action.

However, the Bills defense has allowed a league low nine receptions to opposing tight ends off play action this season. Instead, they have allowed 80.3% of play action passes targeted to running backs or wide receivers to be completed, which is the second-highest rate allowed by a defense in a season since at least 2016.

The Bills have the second-best passing defense in the NFL in yards allowed and rank first in defending quick passes and third in defending short passes. That is where the Eagles want to get him the ball, but they won’t force it against a great defense.

Goedert has three or less catches in eight games this season and I expect this to be another.

Prop bet #3: James Cook longest rush Over 15.5 yards

-114 at FanDuel

James Cook has a slight lead over Jonathan Taylor for the rushing title with two weeks left and I expect him to take advantage of a great matchup here. Cook is second in the NFL in both yards per carry and 10+ yard runs behind only De’Von Achane.

The Eagles defense ranks 21st in the NFL in yards per attempt allowed on the ground. Cook has averaged 6.1 yards per carry when facing a two-high safety shell look, which is the second-most among running backs with at least 50 such carries, trailing only Derrick Henry.

The Eagles defense has aligned with two-high safeties on 77.8% of their snaps this season, which is the second-highest rate in the NFL. Meanwhile, they have loaded the box on a league-low 34.7% of their snaps.

Cook has cleared this number in eight games this season and I expect this to be another one due to the matchup and having space in the run game.

Bet on the NFL at FanDuel!

Make your NFL bets at FanDuel, America's No. 1 sportsbook! Sign up now and by placing $5 on your first bet, you could win $250 in bonus bets if your wager is a winner!

*Eligible U.S. locations only

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Jeremy Jones - Covers
Betting Analyst

Jeremy Jones was born and raised in Lexington, Kentucky and has been a massive Wildcats fans since the moment he came into the world. He wrote his first sports article at the tender age of 11 after attending a local AHL hockey game, and a few years later was writing professionally for sites such as Sports Rants, BetAmerica, and TwinSpires.

Jeremy holds a Masters in Sports Administration from Eastern Kentucky University and utilizes all seven betting options available in Kentucky to shop for odds and promos and find the greatest EV in every wager he places.

His best piece of sports betting advice is to stick to consistent unit sizes for every wager. He acknowledges there will occasionally be a bet that has a huge EV and you can play multiple units in one bet, but cautions against raising your unit size, because you can quickly lose all your winnings if you hit a minor cold streak.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo