After a stretch defined by sustained success but repeated postseason disappointment, the Buffalo Bills moved on from Sean McDermott.
The decision follows another season that ended just short of expectations, as Buffalo once again came up empty in its pursuit of a Super Bowl despite entering the year with championship-level talent.
With the change at the top, the Buffalo Bills’ next head coach odds have begun to take shape, and early market movement is already offering clues as to which direction the franchise may lean.
Buffalo Bills next head coach odds
| Name |  |
|---|---|
| 🏈 Brian Daboll | +210 |
 Davis Webb |
+430 |
 Klint Kubiak |
+450 |
 Joe Brady |
+470 |
| 🏈 Mike McDaniel | +600 |
 Grant Udinski |
+750 |
 Matt LaFleur |
+750 |
| 🏈 Kliff Kingsbury | +900 |
Odds as of 1-19.
Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account
Analyzing the Bills’ next head coach favorites
🏈 Brian Daboll
Brian Daboll’s ties to the Buffalo Bills are well established after helping develop Josh Allen during his time as offensive coordinator.
His recent head-coaching stint with the New York Giants had uneven results, but his reputation as a quarterback-centric coach remains intact.
For the Bills, Daboll would represent a familiar option with a clearer sense of what works and what doesn’t.
Klint Kubiak
The Klint Kubiak appeal is straightforward. The Bills don’t need a full rebuild on offense, and they aren’t searching for a quarterback.
What they’re missing is a fresh voice capable of sharpening the margins, better sequencing, cleaner situational calls, and an approach that translates late in the postseason.
The early betting market movement hints Buffalo could be open to a calculated risk, leaning into offensive upside and allowing Kubiak the runway to develop as a first-time head coach.
For a roster built to win now, that choice would signal a clear belief that innovation, not patience, is the final step.
Joe Brady
Joe Brady has earned praise for stabilizing Buffalo’s offense and helping it regain rhythm late in the season.
Promoting from within would offer continuity at a moment of transition, especially with the quarterback and core pieces already in place.
The question is whether the Bills view Brady as a steady bridge or a long-term answer capable of handling the full demands of a head-coaching role.
Recent Bills coaching history
Coaching stability was hard to find in Buffalo for years, with the Bills cycling through regimes and missing the playoffs throughout much of the 2000s and early 2010s.
That changed when Sean McDermott arrived in 2017. He helped stabilize the franchise, end the playoff drought, and turn Buffalo into a consistent AFC contender. Expectations shifted quickly. Playoff appearances became the standard, not the goal.
But as strong as the regular-season success was, postseason shortcomings began to pile up. Close losses, missed opportunities, and growing questions about game management eventually outweighed McDermott’s role in the rebuild.
Now, Buffalo is back in the coaching market with a rare mix of pressure and opportunity. The Bills aren’t looking for stability anymore. They’re searching for the final piece to push a championship-ready roster over the top.
