MLB Predictions and Moneyline Picks for Saturday, May 9

Saturday’s MLB picks card is loaded with strong pitching matchups, heavy favorites, and a few live underdogs worth backing.

From the Blue Jays and Cubs in favorable spots to the Braves battling the Dodgers late night, these are the MLB moneyline picks standing out most based on current form, pitching edges, and overall team metrics.

MLB moneyline picks for May 9

Matchup	Pick
Angels vs Blue Jays	-186
A's vs Orioles	-122
Astros vs Reds	-156
Rays vs Red Sox	+108
Nationals vs Marlins	+127
Rockies vs Phillies	-170
Twins vs Guardians	-117
Cubs vs Rangers	-133
Tigers vs Royals	+104
Mariners vs White Sox	-117
Yankees vs Brewers	-163
Mets vs Diamondbacks	-127
Cardinals vs Padres	-138
Pirates vs Giants	+100
Braves vs Dodgers	+108

Prices courtesy of Polymarket as of 5-9.

Trade on the MLB at Polymarket!

Sign up now using our exclusive Polymarket promo code 'COVERS' (on your mobile app only) and get a $20 trading bonus after you deposit $20 to trade on any other event contracts — including MLB moneylines!

Sign Up Now at

*Eligible locations only

Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account

Expert MLB moneyline picks for May 9

Angels vs Blue Jays: Blue Jays (-186)

Blue Jays win probability: 65%

Toronto still gets the edge behind Tomoyuki Sugano, who’s been excellent early with a sub-1.00 ERA. The Blue Jays also hold the cleaner overall pitching profile, while the Angels remain vulnerable once traffic starts building on the bases. LA has enough power to stay dangerous, but Toronto looks like the steadier team over nine innings.

A's vs Orioles: Orioles (-122)

Orioles win probability: 55%

This is still an ugly matchup because neither side inspires much confidence on the mound, but Baltimore gets the nod at home. Aaron Civale has pitched well statistically, though the Orioles lineup is capable of creating pressure quickly against contact-heavy arms. Slight edge to Baltimore’s offense and late-game upside.

Astros vs Reds: Reds (-156)

Reds win probability: 61%

Hunter Greene versus Spencer Arrighetti is a much tighter pitching matchup than before, but Cincinnati still has value at home. Greene’s swing-and-miss stuff gives the Reds a real ceiling advantage, and Cincinnati’s bullpen has quietly stabilized lately as well. Houston is dangerous offensively, but the Reds still feel live behind the better strikeout arm.

Rays vs Red Sox: Rays (+108)

Rays win probability: 48%

The Rays remain the cleaner overall team entering this matchup. Better pitching depth, stronger run prevention metrics, and a lineup that consistently pressures defenses with speed. Boston’s offense has been too inconsistent to fully trust right now, especially against deeper staffs.

Nationals vs Marlins: Nationals (+127)

Nationals win probability: 44%

This pitching matchup flipped dramatically, but Washington still has a path because Miami’s offense remains limited overall. Zack Littell’s numbers are ugly, though the Nationals continue to own the stronger power profile and should generate enough offense against a Marlins lineup that struggles to sustain rallies consistently.

Rockies vs Phillies: Phillies (-170)

Phillies win probability: 63%

Aaron Nola’s ERA looks rough, but this still profiles as a bounce-back opportunity against Colorado away from Coors Field. The Phillies lineup is too experienced to stay cold forever, and Kyle Freeland continues to allow plenty of contact and baserunners. Philadelphia remains the more battle-tested offense in this spot.

Twins vs Guardians: Guardians (-117)

Guardians win probability: 54%

This becomes much riskier with Tanner Bibee struggling early, but Cleveland still has the stronger overall run-prevention profile at home. Joe Ryan has been solid, though the Guardians' bullpen remains one of the steadier late-game units in this matchup. Tight game that leans Cleveland in the later innings.

Cubs vs Rangers: Cubs (-133)

Cubs win probability: 57%

Chicago continues to profile as one of the best offenses in baseball, ranking near the top of the league in OPS, OBP, slugging, and runs scored. Edward Cabrera has also been solid lately, while Jack Leiter’s 5.45 ERA and command issues continue to create problems. Big edge to the Cubs offensively.

Tigers vs Royals: Tigers (+104)

Tigers win probability: 49%

This still feels close to a coin flip, but Detroit’s overall pitching profile gives them the slight edge. The Tigers have been steadier in both ERA and WHIP all season, and their bullpen depth remains more trustworthy late. Low-scoring game where one clean inning probably decides it.

Mariners vs White Sox: Mariners (-117)

Mariners win probability: 54%

Luis Castillo’s ERA looks ugly, but Seattle still owns the stronger overall pitching infrastructure entering this matchup. Chicago’s offense has improved statistically, though the White Sox remain vulnerable once games turn into bullpen battles. Seattle’s overall staff depth still separates these teams.

Yankees vs Brewers: Yankees (-163)

Yankees win probability: 62%

Milwaukee’s starter has been excellent, but the Yankees continue to hold massive offensive edges nearly everywhere statistically. New York ranks near the top of baseball in runs, OPS, slugging, and homers, and even against strong pitching, they’re capable of breaking games open quickly. Hard to fade this offense right now.

Mets vs Diamondbacks: Mets (-127)

Mets win probability: 56%

The Mets' offense has been inconsistent, but Clay Holmes versus Merrill Kelly is a sizable statistical pitching mismatch. Holmes has been dominant early with a sub-2.00 ERA, while Kelly’s 9.95 ERA speaks for itself. Arizona can absolutely score, though this matchup heavily favors New York on the mound.

Cardinals vs Padres: Padres (-138)

Padres win probability: 58%

San Diego still gets the edge at home behind the cleaner overall pitching profile. Randy Vasquez has quietly stabilized things lately, while Steven Matz continues to struggle with consistency. The Padres' bullpen and overall run prevention remain stronger entering this matchup.

Pirates vs Giants: Pirates (-100)

Pirates win probability: 50%

This is tougher now because Landen Roupp has pitched well for San Francisco, but the Giants' offense still ranks near the bottom of baseball in nearly every major category. Pittsburgh has simply been the more complete offensive team overall and should create enough chances to stay live here.

Braves vs Dodgers: Braves (+108)

Braves win probability: 48%

Even with Spencer Strider still rounding back into form, Atlanta remains the side because of the overall offensive ceiling and the matchup against Roki Sasaki. The Braves rank near the top of baseball in runs, OPS, and slugging, while Sasaki’s command issues have created major problems early this season. Atlanta still profiles as the more complete side tonight.

Pages related to this topic