Kalshi Lists Mamdani as Heavy Favorite in NYC Mayoral Race

Mamdani's implied probability of a win is 68% higher than that of his closest opponent following Mayor Eric Adams' withdrawal.

Charlotte Capewell • Contributor
Sep 30, 2025 • 15:53 ET • 4 min read
Democratic candidate for mayor of New York City, Zohran Mamdani, waves during a march commemorating Labor Day in New York, United States, 06 september 2025. EFE/ Angel Colmenares /Sipa USA
Photo By - SIPA. Democratic candidate for mayor of New York City, Zohran Mamdani, waves during a march commemorating Labor Day in New York, United States, 06 September 2025. EFE/ Angel Colmenares /Sipa USA

Traders on prediction market Kalshi are now assigning Zohran Mamdani an 84% probability of winning New York City's upcoming mayoral election as of Tuesday morning. The update follows the unexpected exit of Mayor Eric Adams from the race.

Key Takeaways

  • Kalshi is giving Mamdani an 84% chance of becoming NYC mayor after Adams' withdrawal.

  • Andrew Cuomo trails with a 16% probability; Curtis Sliwa holds just 2%.

  • Roughly $28 million has been wagered on the New York mayoral market.

The market, which has drawn just over $28 million in wagers, puts former governor Andrew Cuomo at 16% and Republican Curtis Sliwa at 2%. Mamdani, a 33-year-old democratic socialist, has built his campaign around policies such as free buses, rent freezes, and the establishment of city-owned grocery stores.

The shift came swiftly after Adams announced he would not pursue re-election, citing difficulties raising sufficient funds to run a serious campaign. That withdrawal appears to have consolidated support for Mamdani, with bettors increasingly confident in his path to victory.

Kalshi overtakes Polymarket, solidifying market leadership

Kalshi solidified its leadership of the prediction market arena by dominating Polymarket by volume of trades and worldwide market share. Between Sept. 11-17, Kalshi captured 62% of the combined on-chain volume, surpassing Polymarket's 37%.

In August, Kalshi recorded $875 million in trading volume, behind Polymarket's $1 billion, which illustrates Kalshi's rapid ascent and trajectory. The network has also made strides through grants and partnerships with Web3 platforms to achieve rapid gains in on-chain integration.

Kalshi's strategy is based heavily on U.S. regulation compliance to make it easier for domestic users to access. Coupled with its expansion in sports and events markets, the firm is converting regulatory legitimacy into a competitive advantage.

Mamdani skeptical of NYC casinos

As his front-runner status solidifies via prediction markets, Mamdani's stance on casinos in New York City has drawn attention. At a rally organized by the Hotel and Gaming Trades Council, which backs three prospective casinos, Mamdani responded with measured reluctance when asked whether he would support casino development in the city.

He expressed skepticism, noting potential financial consequences, and declined to offer an explicit endorsement of new casinos in the five boroughs.

Though he opposes casinos in principle, Mamdani has stated he will not actively attempt to block them, acknowledging that city executive power over casino licensing is limited. The state's Gaming Facility Location Board is expected by year's end to award three licenses among eight bids across downstate locations.

Mamdani's stance is one of strategic compromise, indicating he is cautious of potential critics while defying no-licence confrontation to casino-supportive groups. This delicate stance could allow him to retain alliances without going on a pro-casino record.

Pages related to this topic

Charlotte Capewell
Contributor

Charlotte lives and breathes the iGaming world, always eager to uncover the latest scoop. Whether it be new slot launches, the latest regulator news, or overnight affiliate marketing trends, she’s all over it. With plenty of experience covering the pulse of digital casinos, tech innovation, and the evolving US gambling landscape, Charlotte makes complex industry developments feel like a backstage pass to a party.

She deciphers industry maneuvers, mergers, and launches briefly and clearly. Imagine breaking news explained over coffee, not a boardroom memo. Charlotte’s style? No industry jargon, just colourful storytelling, insightful context, and a reporter’s curiosity that takes her from legislative hearings to affiliate roundtables without missing a beat.

Off duty, you might find Charlotte roaming the casino trade floors, notebooks in hand, chatting up compliance officers, platform developers, or slot-machine designers. Pretty much anyone with inside tales. She’s drawn to the energy and the characters, gathering real-world color to fuel her next story. 

And when she’s not chasing the latest gambling headlines? Charlotte is glued to Formula 1 weekends, passionately analyzing team strategies like they’re regulatory frameworks and defending her favorite driver and team with the same fire she brings to a breaking story. Just don’t schedule a call during a Grand Prix.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo