looking for advice

I have two potential trades I'm working on. Non ppo and 6 points for a TD

 I give up Peyton Manning for Chris Johnson

       or

I give up Peyton Manning and Jamal Charles for Turner and Mendenhal

 

Gee thanks for all the advice

chris johnson!!!

Dude quit with the attitude. This forum isn't as busy as most because theres really no gambling involved except the entry. Also, we have no idea who else is on your team. Obviously you seem to really want a RB (s) but I don't know who you would have left if you gave up a peyton manning. If you have Jamal Charles as one of your RB's, obviously you don't have NOTHING.

People really can't help without seeing whos available on waivers, and who you got on your team.

In my league someone traded Ryan Torain for Johnny Knoxx, which in my opinion wasn't a fair trade because Ryan Torain is worth way more than Knoxx is. However, the guy who had Torain was stacked at RB, and the guy who had Knoxx had no RB's, so it worked out for both parties.

So if you were to say Should I trade Peyton Manning for Chris Johnson, but I would be left with Troy Smith? The answer would probably be no.

If you said should I trade Peyton Manning for Chris Johnson and be left with Big Ben, Matt Ryan, etc. etc. the answer would probably be yes.

Thanks slamspur. My back up QB is David Garrard who has a nice schedule the rest of the season except for the giants.

totally agree with Slam
I dont trust Garrard and it seems alot of people are wrapped up in what he did vs Dallas but look at some of the stinkers he put up in the previous weeks he is far from a sure think as Manning is
for me to give you a good opinion let me know what the rest of your team is and Ill do my best, maybe your lacking in wr

6 points for passing touchdowns makes quarterbacks more valuable than in your 4 pt passing leagues.

My second running backs are either Addai or Ronnie Brown.  I look at it that Garrard and Chris Johnson combine for more than Manning and Brown