NHL Anytime Goalscorer Picks for Tonight's Panthers vs Maple Leafs Game 2

Sam Reinhart finds a new gear in the playoffs and he's upped his shot volume in recent contests. With the Maple Leafs forced to turn to backup G Joseph Woll, the Panthers forward is among our favorite options to score.

Todd Cordell - Betting Analyst at Covers.com
Todd Cordell • Betting Analyst
May 7, 2025 • 11:59 ET • 4 min read
Sam Reinhart Florida Panthers NHL
Photo By - Imagn Images. Panthers forward Sam Reinhart celebrates after scoring a goal

Game 1 between the Florida Panthers and Toronto Maple Leafs turned into an offensive explosion with the two sides combining for nine goals and eight different scorers.

Let’s hope for more of the same as we hunt for goals with NHL picks for Wednesday, May 7.

NHL anytime goalscorer picks for Panthers vs Maple Leafs Game 2

  •  Maple Leafs Matthews (+140)
  •  Panthers Reinhart (+180)
  •  Panthers Lundell (+500)

Panthers vs Maple Leafs anytime goalscorer props for tonight

Auston Matthews (+140 at Sports Interaction)

Toronto Maple Leafs captain Auston Matthews was much more productive on home ice this season. He scored in only 38% of his road games compared to a healthy 50% hit rate at Scotiabank. He was especially effective at home down the stretch, scoring 12 times over the final 20 games.

He didn’t find twine in the series opener against the Florida Panthers but had a ton of opportunities. Matthews led all players with 11 shot attempts and six scoring chances despite playing from ahead — and taking fewer chances offensively — for much of the game.

Matthews had several great looks against Sergei Bobrovsky and also missed empty-net attempts, something you wouldn’t generally expect from Matthews.

While Matthews isn’t having his best finishing campaign, production tends to follow when he’s generating such strong shots and scoring chance numbers.

Sam Reinhart (+180 at Sports Interaction)

Sam Reinhart has upped his shot volume of late. He averaged 5.4 attempts per game during the regular season but has generated at least seven in three straight playoff games, piling up 26 along the way.

He is one of the best finishers in the sport, so seeing this kind of volume from him is a sign that goals should soon follow.

Working in Reinhart’s favor is the unfortunate absence of Toronto starting goaltender Anthony Stolarz. Backup Joseph Woll posted much worse numbers during the regular season and was a little vulnerable after being thrown into the fire in Game 1.

Reinhart logged more than 22 minutes in the series opener and recorded strong shot volume. Don’t be surprised if that kind of workload translates to a goal in Game 2.

Anton Lundell (+500 at Sports Interaction)

Anton Lundell often matched up against the Scott Laughton line in Game 1. The Panthers won the shot attempt battle 11-1 and out-scored the Leafs 2-0 when Lundell was on the ice in that matchup. Suffice it to say that Florida’s third-line center convincingly won the battle.

Toronto’s forward depth — or lack thereof — has been a talking point all season long and for good reason. It’s a problem and one Lundell and a loaded Panthers third line will continue taking advantage of.

Lundell ranked tied for fifth on the Panthers in expected goals in Game 1 (he had a couple of good shooting opportunities that missed the net) and recorded at least five shots on goal in the two games prior. He’s constantly threatening against the Maple Leafs.

At such a juicy price point, it’s worth taking a flier on the underrated two-way pivot.

Sports Interaction: Canada’s home for NHL

Looking to bet on some NHL Playoffs action? Join Sports Interaction, the best in Canada for new bettors, and get a 125% bonus on your first deposit (up to $250)!

*Not available in Ontario. 19+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Todd Cordell - Covers
Betting Analyst

Todd Cordell is a data-driven betting analyst. He uses numbers to help identify value across a wide variety of sports, with NHL being his specialty. Shot props, in particular, have proven to be a very fruitful market. Todd has served as a betting analyst in the public sphere for many years, most recently with theScore covering the NHL and MLB.

When not writing about sports betting, Todd stays busy analyzing the New Jersey Devils with a fine-tooth comb for InfernalAccess, his Devils-centric blog. Todd attended Sheridan College and graduated in 2014 with a diploma in print journalism.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo