Would you return $45k if you found it?

knowing my luck it would turn out to be counterfeit

no

Was the house being sold "As is?" 

I would triple it, then return 10%

I'll be honest. I would've kept all of it.

I would have kept it in this situation.

If I found a wallet in the streets I wouldn't touch the money though.

My thoughts exactly.

HELL NO, my motto is "IF YOU FIND IT, IT WAS MEANT TO BE YOURS!!!!!!!" Look at it as being rewarded for giving money for the purpose of good!!

hells to the nah!

anyways i read some of the replys above my post and i have a story

this reminds me, i have a thousand in the wall in case i get divorced

asking a question like this here is just silly. i, as a gambler, would keep it. but you got to give the man credit for doing something maybe 1 out of every 50 people would do. didnt seem like an overzealous do gooder trying to preach his religous shit on us. he just said he wants to set a good example for his kids, he admitted his temptations to keep it, and any guy that says 'rediculously awesome' has to be pretty down to earth in my mind. if there is an afterlife, this guy gets a nice plot of land up there. hopefully one day when i have the responsibilty of children and a wife, my perception about the value of money and integrity will be more like this guys. kudos to him

i agree though about the wallet situation having nothing in common with this. 45,000 found the way this guy did would lead me to the obvious conclusion that old man river who i bought the house from croaked, never got a chance to leave this money to anyone, and its clear through the wear and aging of the money that this isnt a sketchy situation, just simply dumb luck. 

I would gamble the 40k and make myself a profit and then give back the original 40k

 

 

 

As a former realtor, it's buyer beware, and do a home inspection.

I would keep it .

Ironically, my terminally ill  Mother is having me help her clean out her house and she already has told me about a Stamp Collection, Bonds, Coin Collection, some Stocks etc that were left to me by my father so I guess I have some 'found ' money to collect. ..It's probably 25-50K  based on her estimate.

 

 

Completely different. You sir are a THIEF.

How are you greedy if you FIND something in a attic?

I couldn't keep it.  It wouldn't be able to stop thinking about the fact that it wasn't mine. 

What I don't understand is how you can have that much cash lying around with nothing documented as to what is where. 

I have a document that details every single account I have along with user names and pin numbers.  Would it really be hard to add, "cash in ammo boxes in garage?" 

Also, it sounds like the family just left some of this stuff for the new owners to clean out.  That's a crap move.  I don't know about you guys, but when my grandparents died we spent mucho time going through EVERYTHING before the house was cleaned out and then sold. 

But I'll tell you one thing, if they didn't give me a $5K reward or something, I'd end up being a bit miffed.  

Hutch-

My Father and now my Mother grew up in the  1940's/50's and both did very well in life.

But as I stated, it's not that uncommon  for people of that generation to not be organized... Thankfully, I have convinced my mother.

 

I believe you are right.  In fact, when my dad figured out his retirement date, us kids got together and in 3 or so separate nights over a 1 month period, proceeded to clean up all his crap that he had been keeping around.  Papers he had not business keeping.  Organized all of his stuff and made sure he had his affairs in order.  We also went to a meeting with his financial planning institution so we understand what money is where.

I know that generation was a bit different that way, but wouldn't you as a child at least talk to your father about his affairs if he is at that age?  I'm not blaming him, I'm blaming the kids.  The stigma of it being taboo to ask about money affairs is OVA.  They should know better IMO.

Hope all is well. 

I would. After 52 years of walking this planet, I can assure you Karma exists.

That's a weak excuse. You'll get yours.