Expensive Box of Chocolates

Brady, Wilson, Rodgers, Roethlisberger, Peyton, Eli, Flacco, Brees

Imitation Can of Crab meat

Rivers, Stafford, Luck, Dalton, Romo, Alex Smith, Ryan, Newton, Kapernick

Bag of Trail Mix

Cutler, Palmer, Hoyer, Tannehill, Locker, Geno Smith, Schaub, Cassel, Henne

The jury box group

Bortles, Bridgewater, Foles, Manuel, Carr, Glennon, Griffin III, Bradford, Keenum

The Box of Band Aids

Vick, Fitzpactrick

Your covers account should be banned for life for putting Tannehill in the same group as Henne, Locker, Geno Smith, Matt Cassell and Matt Shaub.

All those guys combined couldn't throw for 4000 yards, 27 TDS and 400 rushing yards in 1 season

My thoughts on Tannehill are well documented and I'm sure people are sick of hearing them so will keep this very short.

In the last 2 years he had 10 opportunities to lead his team to tie or win in the last few minutes of the 4th Q. he is 7/10 in those opportunities.

4000 yards passing, 27 TDS in the air, one of (if not) the best running QB in the league. Completed 14 passes in a row 3 times, with a bad offensive line and average receiving core. His team was also near the top of the list in drops (can remember clearly 3-4 times his WR's dropped open TD passes)...Also tough as nails. 48/48 in starts even though he gets drilled every single game with over 100 sacks the last 2 season.

So no, I respectably disagree that he doesn't have the IT factor or is not the answer. ESPECIALLY considering the Dolphins QBs the last 15 years. The Dolphins GM's also agree with me because he will be getting a long term contract.

QB A: 18 TDs, 3,127 yards, 12 INTS

QB B: 19 TDs, 3,369 yards, 10 INTs

QB C: 19 TDs, 3,398 yards, 17 INTs

QB D: 27 TDs, 4,045 yards, 12 INTs

QB A - Newton

QB B - Kap

QB C - Dalton

QB D - Tannehill

Have some respect for Tannehill, the numbers speak for themselves. "Still not a QB and does good enough."....Uh yeah, by those numbers I'd say he does good enough

Here are my ranks quick off top of my head.

Tier 1:

1 - Rodgers

2- Brady

3- Brees

4 - Manning

5 - Wison

6 - Romo

7 - Luck

8 - Ryan

9 - Big Ben

Tier 2:

10 - Rivers

11 - Tannehill

12 - Flacco

13 - Stafford

14 - Foles

15 - Eli Manning

16 - Newton

17 - Kap

18 - Dalton

Tier 3:

19 - Bridgewater

20 - Cutler

21 - Alex Smith

22 - Derek Carr

23 - Mark Sanchez

24 - Matt Moore

tier 4 (Trash)

25 - Hoyer

26 - Geno Smith

27 - Bortles (a lot of room for improvement)

28 - Cassell

29 - Mccown

30 - Austin Davis.

Not rocket science

Austin Davis has 2 good starts basically in his entire NFL Career. His best game was against the pitiful Eagles secondary in a game they were losing by 20 points the entire game, thus building his stats. McCown threw for 13 TDs and 1 INT two years ago

Quote Originally Posted by totallypsycho:



i rate lamar miller, knowshon moreno, and mike wallace highly and the fins' d VERY highly if that makes you feel any better.

honestly, 13-18 are all really close for me. the reason i put newton/kaep/dalton is because they've played at high levels in the past and just had relatively down years imo. if tannehill has another season like the one he did last year i'd move him up. but i also honestly think you have to have an innate understanding of x and o to be a truly great qb, and i haven't seen that from tannehill yet so far. we'll see what happens next season 

Lamar Miller is very solid. Over 1,000 yards and 5.1 YPC. He just doesn't get the ball enough.

Reminds me of Rogers. 

Raiders: If free agency goes well Randal Cobb/Julius or draft at #4 WR, I believe Carr puts up big numbers this year. Carr is a natural thrower, strong arm with a quick release.  He’s athletic enough to get outside the pocket and make big throws down the field. Most important factors: he’s smart, hard worker and an overachiever.  Raiders 71.05 lead the league in TD Red Zone Scoring Percentage with no weapons on offense.   

Raiders scored Big Time with Carr

Oh Wait ......Eli beat Brady twice in Super Bowls as a 12 pt dog and a 3 pt dog. Yet Eli is put in a Tier 2 group and Romo who has nothing to show for is in the Tier 1 group. I DON'T THINK SO. Eli forgot what Romo is trying to learn.