If you had to choose between Vick as your starter or Tebow?
Who would would you pick?
I would pick Tebow without question. Tebow has all the right characteristics i like in a football player. Guts and heart and a good ole never say die attitude. He leaves it out on the field every time he steps out there. Tebow will kill himself to win!
Tebow has all the winning intangibles. Everyone says that Vick needs a supporting cast? From what i have seen Tebow do so far and what i saw Vick do last night? I know for sure that Tebow would have played much better than Vick if placed in the exact same situation!
I don't care about Vicks criminal history or any of that! I am making an observation based on the football player. Nothing personal.
Tebow can stand in the pocket and has a strong throwing arm. He has quick feet and can move around in the pocket with out being all jittery and jumpy like Vick.
Tebow will stand back there till the end even if it means his head!
Give me a choice of who i want leading my team with 2 minutes left on the clock down a score on my own 20?
If you were in the huddle? Tell me who's face you would believe in more to get the job done?
I know Vick has been to the playoffs and has lead a winning team already but right now from what i see... it looks like Vick's career is done as a starter and i don't think i would want him as my back up either!
I will take willingness to be coached, listen and learn. Plus guts, heart and mental toughness over experience!
I am probably going to get shit on for this thread
If you had to choose between Vick as your starter or Tebow?
Who would would you pick?
I would pick Tebow without question. Tebow has all the right characteristics i like in a football player. Guts and heart and a good ole never say die attitude. He leaves it out on the field every time he steps out there. Tebow will kill himself to win!
Tebow has all the winning intangibles. Everyone says that Vick needs a supporting cast? From what i have seen Tebow do so far and what i saw Vick do last night? I know for sure that Tebow would have played much better than Vick if placed in the exact same situation!
I don't care about Vicks criminal history or any of that! I am making an observation based on the football player. Nothing personal.
Tebow can stand in the pocket and has a strong throwing arm. He has quick feet and can move around in the pocket with out being all jittery and jumpy like Vick.
Tebow will stand back there till the end even if it means his head!
Give me a choice of who i want leading my team with 2 minutes left on the clock down a score on my own 20?
If you were in the huddle? Tell me who's face you would believe in more to get the job done?
I know Vick has been to the playoffs and has lead a winning team already but right now from what i see... it looks like Vick's career is done as a starter and i don't think i would want him as my back up either!
I will take willingness to be coached, listen and learn. Plus guts, heart and mental toughness over experience!
I am probably going to get shit on for this thread
Both can't throw accurately for shit right now. Is neither an option
The finger is also an option one finger down though.Well one looks like a football player the other looks like he's lostand confused. Keep the shit commin
Both can't throw accurately for shit right now. Is neither an option
The finger is also an option one finger down though.Well one looks like a football player the other looks like he's lostand confused. Keep the shit commin
Tebow can stand in the pocket and has a strong throwing arm. He has quick feet and can move around in the pocket with out being all jittery and jumpy like Vick.
Vick has twice the arm that tebow has and has led his team to the NFC championship.
He might be a bone head qb but thats coaching. No one has taught him HOW to be a qb instead or just a runner
Tebow can stand in the pocket and has a strong throwing arm. He has quick feet and can move around in the pocket with out being all jittery and jumpy like Vick.
Vick has twice the arm that tebow has and has led his team to the NFC championship.
He might be a bone head qb but thats coaching. No one has taught him HOW to be a qb instead or just a runner
Tebow can stand in the pocket and has a strong throwing arm. He has quick feet and can move around in the pocket with out being all jittery and jumpy like Vick.
Vick has twice the arm that tebow has and has led his team to the NFC championship.
He might be a bone head qb but thats coaching. No one has taught him HOW to be a qb instead or just a runner
6 years in the league and still plays like a jumpy, lost, rookie college QB? When i saw vick throw that 1st pick straight to the bengals player!
I mean directly at his numbers!
The first thing that came to mind was... vick has not improved at all as a QB.
That was one of the dumbest throws i have ever seen?
Making bone head rookie mistakes after this many years in the league?
Tebow can stand in the pocket and has a strong throwing arm. He has quick feet and can move around in the pocket with out being all jittery and jumpy like Vick.
Vick has twice the arm that tebow has and has led his team to the NFC championship.
He might be a bone head qb but thats coaching. No one has taught him HOW to be a qb instead or just a runner
6 years in the league and still plays like a jumpy, lost, rookie college QB? When i saw vick throw that 1st pick straight to the bengals player!
I mean directly at his numbers!
The first thing that came to mind was... vick has not improved at all as a QB.
That was one of the dumbest throws i have ever seen?
Making bone head rookie mistakes after this many years in the league?
your going to base this off one pre season game? He should be better than what he is no doubt, but i would take Vick over tebow in a second
True! Tebow hasn't played much! I am basing it on the chance of success! Like i said he has all the makings of a winning football player! Look at all the intangibles Tebow brings to the field. I wish i had him on my team! Just to be on the sidelines. I used to be a huge Vick fan! After what i have seen through out his career. I haven't seen anything that tells me he has the winning qualities that i expected him to have by now
your going to base this off one pre season game? He should be better than what he is no doubt, but i would take Vick over tebow in a second
True! Tebow hasn't played much! I am basing it on the chance of success! Like i said he has all the makings of a winning football player! Look at all the intangibles Tebow brings to the field. I wish i had him on my team! Just to be on the sidelines. I used to be a huge Vick fan! After what i have seen through out his career. I haven't seen anything that tells me he has the winning qualities that i expected him to have by now
The finger is also an option one finger down though.Well one looks like a football player the other looks like he's lostand confused. Keep the shit commin
I'm going off what I saw from Tebow in college. I went to Florida. He's got a LOOOOOOOONG way to go. His footwork on the run is a mess and the reworked delivery is still too long given the talent around him. Also when scrambling now he has the same problem as Vick in how he holds the ball. Neither will be much more than a runner out of the "wildcat" next year.
The finger is also an option one finger down though.Well one looks like a football player the other looks like he's lostand confused. Keep the shit commin
I'm going off what I saw from Tebow in college. I went to Florida. He's got a LOOOOOOOONG way to go. His footwork on the run is a mess and the reworked delivery is still too long given the talent around him. Also when scrambling now he has the same problem as Vick in how he holds the ball. Neither will be much more than a runner out of the "wildcat" next year.
Thanks for the debate guys Killed sometime on this subject. I need to get something to eat before the atlanta braves game starts in about 30 minutes so i can drink some brew. Hate drinking on an empty stomach. Will be back later to see if their are anymore attacks! I guess it only me and coach josh mcdaniels that see tebow is a real football player!I knew i wouldn't find anyone who would agree with me!
Thanks for the debate guys Killed sometime on this subject. I need to get something to eat before the atlanta braves game starts in about 30 minutes so i can drink some brew. Hate drinking on an empty stomach. Will be back later to see if their are anymore attacks! I guess it only me and coach josh mcdaniels that see tebow is a real football player!I knew i wouldn't find anyone who would agree with me!
If your talking about both fresh outa college I would take Vick hands down.
If youare talking about right now I would take Vick hands down.
I know Vick looked like shit last night. But Vick also looked amazing to me last week . So Im not sure what happened last night but I dont see many more performances like that. Vick has a stronger and believe it or not a more accurate arm. Vick is still the best athlete playing at the QB position in the NFL. Vick has won in this league. Vick also has alot more talent around him the Tebow. There is no way in hell you will ever get me to pick a QB who hasnt even played in a game over a Qb who has led his team to playoff wins. IMO
If your talking about both fresh outa college I would take Vick hands down.
If youare talking about right now I would take Vick hands down.
I know Vick looked like shit last night. But Vick also looked amazing to me last week . So Im not sure what happened last night but I dont see many more performances like that. Vick has a stronger and believe it or not a more accurate arm. Vick is still the best athlete playing at the QB position in the NFL. Vick has won in this league. Vick also has alot more talent around him the Tebow. There is no way in hell you will ever get me to pick a QB who hasnt even played in a game over a Qb who has led his team to playoff wins. IMO
I mean who would you want as a back up more vick or tebow?
As a backup? Hmmmm. Vick might b more of a distraction to a team. NFL-capability wise it's Vick, but if you factor personality issues, then who knows, depends on the team. Neither would make their team a winner.
I mean who would you want as a back up more vick or tebow?
As a backup? Hmmmm. Vick might b more of a distraction to a team. NFL-capability wise it's Vick, but if you factor personality issues, then who knows, depends on the team. Neither would make their team a winner.
If your talking about both fresh outa college I would take Vick hands down.
If youare talking about right now I would take Vick hands down.
I know Vick looked like shit last night. But Vick also looked amazing to me last week . So Im not sure what happened last night but I dont see many more performances like that. Vick has a stronger and believe it or not a more accurate arm. Vick is still the best athlete playing at the QB position in the NFL. Vick has won in this league. Vick also has alot more talent around him the Tebow. There is no way in hell you will ever get me to pick a QB who hasnt even played in a game over a Qb who has led his team to playoff wins. IMO
Vick has been exposed. Vick has had time to improve and still looks like a scrambling rookie. He cant stay in the pocket. He doesn't trust his protection. He can only read on side of the field. For every 5 good passes an interception and a sack come directly after.
Accuracy and vick don't even belong in the same sentence? I believe Tebow is stronger and smarter and way more accurate in the pocket and especially on the move. Tebow has way more mental and physical toughness.
Better teammate and is an amazing field general. If i was in the huddle? I would follow him on the field. I believe he would sacrifice what ever it takes to get the win at all cost. Tebow shows no fear. Vick looks scared and uncertain every time i see him play.
After all these years... vick still looks like he has no idea what is happening on the field?
If i was building a team and i had to chose one of the two to lead my team to victory i would chose Tebow!
We will see in the coming years....who is a starter in the NFL and who is a bench warmer if that...maybe unemployed. Vick looks like AFL material to me right now. I hope i am wrong!
If your talking about both fresh outa college I would take Vick hands down.
If youare talking about right now I would take Vick hands down.
I know Vick looked like shit last night. But Vick also looked amazing to me last week . So Im not sure what happened last night but I dont see many more performances like that. Vick has a stronger and believe it or not a more accurate arm. Vick is still the best athlete playing at the QB position in the NFL. Vick has won in this league. Vick also has alot more talent around him the Tebow. There is no way in hell you will ever get me to pick a QB who hasnt even played in a game over a Qb who has led his team to playoff wins. IMO
Vick has been exposed. Vick has had time to improve and still looks like a scrambling rookie. He cant stay in the pocket. He doesn't trust his protection. He can only read on side of the field. For every 5 good passes an interception and a sack come directly after.
Accuracy and vick don't even belong in the same sentence? I believe Tebow is stronger and smarter and way more accurate in the pocket and especially on the move. Tebow has way more mental and physical toughness.
Better teammate and is an amazing field general. If i was in the huddle? I would follow him on the field. I believe he would sacrifice what ever it takes to get the win at all cost. Tebow shows no fear. Vick looks scared and uncertain every time i see him play.
After all these years... vick still looks like he has no idea what is happening on the field?
If i was building a team and i had to chose one of the two to lead my team to victory i would chose Tebow!
We will see in the coming years....who is a starter in the NFL and who is a bench warmer if that...maybe unemployed. Vick looks like AFL material to me right now. I hope i am wrong!
If you choose to make use of any information on this website including online sports betting services from any websites that may be featured on this website, we strongly recommend that you carefully check your local laws before doing so. It is your sole responsibility to understand your local laws and observe them strictly. Covers does not provide any advice or guidance as to the legality of online sports betting or other online gambling activities within your jurisdiction and you are responsible for complying with laws that are applicable to you in your relevant locality. Covers disclaims all liability associated with your use of this website and use of any information contained on it. As a condition of using this website, you agree to hold the owner of this website harmless from any claims arising from your use of any services on any third party website that may be featured by Covers.