I used to love rodgers for the GOAT, but its just not realistic because of bradys rings which are team accolades. But anyway, who do you guys think is more talented playing the position? I think its an easy one, stats and eye test will back it up as well...
I used to love rodgers for the GOAT, but its just not realistic because of bradys rings which are team accolades. But anyway, who do you guys think is more talented playing the position? I think its an easy one, stats and eye test will back it up as well...
Rogers? He’s not even sniffing Brady’s jock strap. Maybe in his prime. Fact of the matter is Rogers pads his stats. He’ll take a sack or throw ball away just so he doesn’t throw an INT. He plays for himself. Of course they all do since money talks. Sorry but if you’re going to put current QB for QB it’s Brees and Brady. Bree’s owns the records until he got hurt. He’d have broken the TD record. Which he’ll beat Brady in it still. He’s a yr younger and surpassed Brady. Rogers is done.
Rogers? He’s not even sniffing Brady’s jock strap. Maybe in his prime. Fact of the matter is Rogers pads his stats. He’ll take a sack or throw ball away just so he doesn’t throw an INT. He plays for himself. Of course they all do since money talks. Sorry but if you’re going to put current QB for QB it’s Brees and Brady. Bree’s owns the records until he got hurt. He’d have broken the TD record. Which he’ll beat Brady in it still. He’s a yr younger and surpassed Brady. Rogers is done.
Rogers? He’s not even sniffing Brady’s jock strap. Maybe in his prime. Fact of the matter is Rogers pads his stats. He’ll take a sack or throw ball away just so he doesn’t throw an INT. He plays for himself. Of course they all do since money talks. Sorry but if you’re going to put current QB for QB it’s Brees and Brady. Bree’s owns the records until he got hurt. He’d have broken the TD record. Which he’ll beat Brady in it still. He’s a yr younger and surpassed Brady. Rogers is done.
Interesting, rodgers does lead many QB stats for all time history and averages better regualr season numbers then brady per 16 game season. I dont see how you can be so so high on brees but just throw Rodgers to the side
Rogers? He’s not even sniffing Brady’s jock strap. Maybe in his prime. Fact of the matter is Rogers pads his stats. He’ll take a sack or throw ball away just so he doesn’t throw an INT. He plays for himself. Of course they all do since money talks. Sorry but if you’re going to put current QB for QB it’s Brees and Brady. Bree’s owns the records until he got hurt. He’d have broken the TD record. Which he’ll beat Brady in it still. He’s a yr younger and surpassed Brady. Rogers is done.
Interesting, rodgers does lead many QB stats for all time history and averages better regualr season numbers then brady per 16 game season. I dont see how you can be so so high on brees but just throw Rodgers to the side
Rogers has the best TD/INT ratio. As a quartback, NOT team accolades; how does Rogers compare to Brees other than stay I mentioned? Forget wins/losses. Stats, Brees has shattered record books. He’s had less than Brady to work with. A more difficult division.
Rogers...took Farves team, and managed it successfully. Not saying he’s not a great QB. But if you’re going to pit QB vs QB and you’re putting Brady in it? Look at Brees numbers and you’ll surely see he’s above Rogers in the stats.
Rogers has the best TD/INT ratio. As a quartback, NOT team accolades; how does Rogers compare to Brees other than stay I mentioned? Forget wins/losses. Stats, Brees has shattered record books. He’s had less than Brady to work with. A more difficult division.
Rogers...took Farves team, and managed it successfully. Not saying he’s not a great QB. But if you’re going to pit QB vs QB and you’re putting Brady in it? Look at Brees numbers and you’ll surely see he’s above Rogers in the stats.
I get your point. I was just simply wondering when it comes to those two who is more talented between those two and from my view i give rodgers the upper hand
I get your point. I was just simply wondering when it comes to those two who is more talented between those two and from my view i give rodgers the upper hand
Here’s the thing to look at. Owners and Coaching. Bar none, Kraft and Belichick outweigh anyone. They made Brady who he was. It could’ve been Almost ANY QB who’s above avg and he’d have pretty close to Brady. Both in rings and records. An nfl financial advisor will get some pretty good tips to the hat don’t you think? Take Kraft out and Patriots wouldn’t be the team they are today. Fact....
Here’s the thing to look at. Owners and Coaching. Bar none, Kraft and Belichick outweigh anyone. They made Brady who he was. It could’ve been Almost ANY QB who’s above avg and he’d have pretty close to Brady. Both in rings and records. An nfl financial advisor will get some pretty good tips to the hat don’t you think? Take Kraft out and Patriots wouldn’t be the team they are today. Fact....
Here’s the thing to look at. Owners and Coaching. Bar none, Kraft and Belichick outweigh anyone. They made Brady who he was. It could’ve been Almost ANY QB who’s above avg and he’d have pretty close to Brady. Both in rings and records. An nfl financial advisor will get some pretty good tips to the hat don’t you think? Take Kraft out and Patriots wouldn’t be the team they are today. Fact....
Agreed on that. I always said through the Brady years it was more Belichek then him. This is why this argument comes up in my daily life so much because 99% of the public is convinced Brady is the most skillful QB of all time and he deserves all praise for the pats winning over the years. Not trying to disrespect the dude but I feel real football analysts can see through the lines. Well at least no football analyst should ever call Brady the best football player to ever play...
Here’s the thing to look at. Owners and Coaching. Bar none, Kraft and Belichick outweigh anyone. They made Brady who he was. It could’ve been Almost ANY QB who’s above avg and he’d have pretty close to Brady. Both in rings and records. An nfl financial advisor will get some pretty good tips to the hat don’t you think? Take Kraft out and Patriots wouldn’t be the team they are today. Fact....
Agreed on that. I always said through the Brady years it was more Belichek then him. This is why this argument comes up in my daily life so much because 99% of the public is convinced Brady is the most skillful QB of all time and he deserves all praise for the pats winning over the years. Not trying to disrespect the dude but I feel real football analysts can see through the lines. Well at least no football analyst should ever call Brady the best football player to ever play...
More talented ? Rodgers by miles. Brady has played with a top 5 defense his entire career. Rodgers has lost games where he went off and dropped 35 + points.
Put Brady on GB with Mike McCarthy and no defense and he’s nothing but a glorified Alex Smith. FOOH with this BS.
Rodgers in New England with a top defense and Belichick and McDaniels? Are you kidding me.
Check down Tommy is put in the best situation to succeed than any QB in NFL history. The guy is literally asked to deliver a 5-7 yard pass to a wide open receiver with max protection..
More talented ? Rodgers by miles. Brady has played with a top 5 defense his entire career. Rodgers has lost games where he went off and dropped 35 + points.
Put Brady on GB with Mike McCarthy and no defense and he’s nothing but a glorified Alex Smith. FOOH with this BS.
Rodgers in New England with a top defense and Belichick and McDaniels? Are you kidding me.
Check down Tommy is put in the best situation to succeed than any QB in NFL history. The guy is literally asked to deliver a 5-7 yard pass to a wide open receiver with max protection..
More talented ? Rodgers by miles. Brady has played with a top 5 defense his entire career. Rodgers has lost games where he went off and dropped 35 + points.Put Brady on GB with Mike McCarthy and no defense and he’s nothing but a glorified Alex Smith. FOOH with this BS.Rodgers in New England with a top defense and Belichick and McDaniels? Are you kidding me.Check down Tommy is put in the best situation to succeed than any QB in NFL history. The guy is literally asked to deliver a 5-7 yard pass to a wide open receiver with max protection..
Fully agree with this, yet most people cant seem to even understand this simple concept
More talented ? Rodgers by miles. Brady has played with a top 5 defense his entire career. Rodgers has lost games where he went off and dropped 35 + points.Put Brady on GB with Mike McCarthy and no defense and he’s nothing but a glorified Alex Smith. FOOH with this BS.Rodgers in New England with a top defense and Belichick and McDaniels? Are you kidding me.Check down Tommy is put in the best situation to succeed than any QB in NFL history. The guy is literally asked to deliver a 5-7 yard pass to a wide open receiver with max protection..
Fully agree with this, yet most people cant seem to even understand this simple concept
is it tho? It is a team sport right? and the question was about pure talent?
It never made sense to me how winning in the NFL or in any sport=best. Brady stans cant come up with any other reason of why hes the most skillful QB other than that he wins. That is why the GOAT debate should be done because I guess we just give the GOAT award to whoever wins the most, but thats fine with me I guess. What I care is who is better/talented, not whos team has been better the past couple decades...
is it tho? It is a team sport right? and the question was about pure talent?
It never made sense to me how winning in the NFL or in any sport=best. Brady stans cant come up with any other reason of why hes the most skillful QB other than that he wins. That is why the GOAT debate should be done because I guess we just give the GOAT award to whoever wins the most, but thats fine with me I guess. What I care is who is better/talented, not whos team has been better the past couple decades...
This one question is going to sum up why winning shouldnt impact who is more talented.
Here it is:
Brady might win more, but when Rodgers loses, how many of those losses are really on him? How many are really like, damn aaron you gotta make that play right there...
Less than 5% of the losses are, I have been watching Aaron since the beginning and only a handful of times was I like "No Rodgers you had to do that right there". So thats what no one talks about too, why does Brady win and why does Rodgers lose? Thats what people should discuss
This one question is going to sum up why winning shouldnt impact who is more talented.
Here it is:
Brady might win more, but when Rodgers loses, how many of those losses are really on him? How many are really like, damn aaron you gotta make that play right there...
Less than 5% of the losses are, I have been watching Aaron since the beginning and only a handful of times was I like "No Rodgers you had to do that right there". So thats what no one talks about too, why does Brady win and why does Rodgers lose? Thats what people should discuss
Rogers? He’s not even sniffing Brady’s jock strap. Maybe in his prime. Fact of the matter is Rogers pads his stats. He’ll take a sack or throw ball away just so he doesn’t throw an INT. He plays for himself. Of course they all do since money talks. Sorry but if you’re going to put current QB for QB it’s Brees and Brady. Bree’s owns the records until he got hurt. He’d have broken the TD record. Which he’ll beat Brady in it still. He’s a yr younger and surpassed Brady. Rogers is done.
One of the dumbest comments I've ever read on here. He pads his stats by taking a sack or throwing the ball away so he doesn't throw an INT? That's what you would want your QB to do, sack or throwing the ball away isn't going to be a turnover like an INT is. Granted, I agree with everything else you said but that sentence got me.
Rogers? He’s not even sniffing Brady’s jock strap. Maybe in his prime. Fact of the matter is Rogers pads his stats. He’ll take a sack or throw ball away just so he doesn’t throw an INT. He plays for himself. Of course they all do since money talks. Sorry but if you’re going to put current QB for QB it’s Brees and Brady. Bree’s owns the records until he got hurt. He’d have broken the TD record. Which he’ll beat Brady in it still. He’s a yr younger and surpassed Brady. Rogers is done.
One of the dumbest comments I've ever read on here. He pads his stats by taking a sack or throwing the ball away so he doesn't throw an INT? That's what you would want your QB to do, sack or throwing the ball away isn't going to be a turnover like an INT is. Granted, I agree with everything else you said but that sentence got me.
Rodgers is a lot more talented than Brady.. his deep passes are more accurate, he leads his receivers better than Brady. He is able to escape the pocket and still complete the ball. He is also capable of picking up a first down with his legs.
brady relies on quick releases, checkdowns and YAC. He is very smart at choosing his target presnap, he already knows which one has the best chance at catching the football just by reading the defense before the ball is snapped.
Rodgers is a lot more talented than Brady.. his deep passes are more accurate, he leads his receivers better than Brady. He is able to escape the pocket and still complete the ball. He is also capable of picking up a first down with his legs.
brady relies on quick releases, checkdowns and YAC. He is very smart at choosing his target presnap, he already knows which one has the best chance at catching the football just by reading the defense before the ball is snapped.
I love Brady bashing. Too slow, 5 yard paper cuts, super model wife, fragile, Belicheck does it all...... I hate the Pats mentality. Yes, 80 Percent of America wants the Patriots to fail....fine. This stupid crap clouds the argument.
Long term talent.....student of the game....game manager.....superbowl rings.....the best in game adjustments and changing the play based on Defense -- IT IS BRADY.
2019 more Talented -- I would take Rodgers after 5 games.
I love Brady bashing. Too slow, 5 yard paper cuts, super model wife, fragile, Belicheck does it all...... I hate the Pats mentality. Yes, 80 Percent of America wants the Patriots to fail....fine. This stupid crap clouds the argument.
Long term talent.....student of the game....game manager.....superbowl rings.....the best in game adjustments and changing the play based on Defense -- IT IS BRADY.
2019 more Talented -- I would take Rodgers after 5 games.
Brady is the GOAT. He adapts to any situation and WINS. He does what you call dink and dunk when that's the build. He does the deep ball when he has the deep ball receivers. He does it all. Is he a running back hybrid QB? No. Is he the best QB to ever do it? Yes.
Brady is the GOAT. He adapts to any situation and WINS. He does what you call dink and dunk when that's the build. He does the deep ball when he has the deep ball receivers. He does it all. Is he a running back hybrid QB? No. Is he the best QB to ever do it? Yes.
You all think peppering those 5-15 yard passes to Edelman in tight tight pockets with absolute exceptional precision in any given situation is something that anyone can do? Do you know the risk if those short passes get intercepted. It's going to the other teams home. But that game play doesn't define Brady
You all think peppering those 5-15 yard passes to Edelman in tight tight pockets with absolute exceptional precision in any given situation is something that anyone can do? Do you know the risk if those short passes get intercepted. It's going to the other teams home. But that game play doesn't define Brady
Brady is the GOAT. He adapts to any situation and WINS. He does what you call dink and dunk when that's the build. He does the deep ball when he has the deep ball receivers. He does it all. Is he a running back hybrid QB? No. Is he the best QB to ever do it? Yes. And I see Pat Mahomes.
This is the problem with Brady backers in this argument. All you can bring up is winning when that is a team element and his teams with coaching have been the best his whole career. Winning does matter but in a 1 v 1 debate, winning in football can not be the #1 reason for who is a better player...
Brady is the GOAT. He adapts to any situation and WINS. He does what you call dink and dunk when that's the build. He does the deep ball when he has the deep ball receivers. He does it all. Is he a running back hybrid QB? No. Is he the best QB to ever do it? Yes. And I see Pat Mahomes.
This is the problem with Brady backers in this argument. All you can bring up is winning when that is a team element and his teams with coaching have been the best his whole career. Winning does matter but in a 1 v 1 debate, winning in football can not be the #1 reason for who is a better player...
If you choose to make use of any information on this website including online sports betting services from any websites that may be featured on this website, we strongly recommend that you carefully check your local laws before doing so. It is your sole responsibility to understand your local laws and observe them strictly. Covers does not provide any advice or guidance as to the legality of online sports betting or other online gambling activities within your jurisdiction and you are responsible for complying with laws that are applicable to you in your relevant locality. Covers disclaims all liability associated with your use of this website and use of any information contained on it. As a condition of using this website, you agree to hold the owner of this website harmless from any claims arising from your use of any services on any third party website that may be featured by Covers.