LAS VEGAS (Reuters) - The ATP has reversed its decision to award James Blake a quarter-final berth at the Las Vegas Open, after bending a rule to allow him through.
Russian Evgeny Korolev, who should have gone through under the rules, will now take his place in the last eight.
Needing to beat Argentine Juan Martin del Potro with the loss of no more than five games to advance on Thursday, top seed Blake was leading 6-1 3-1 when his opponent retired because of breathing problems.
Blake was then told he would not progress as the rules stated games won or lost in a walkover did not count and that Korolev would go through on a head-to-head basis after the Russian beat the American earlier in the competition.
After lengthy discussions the ATP backtracked and awarded Blake a place in the last eight, only to change its decision again on Friday.
In a statement, the ATP said "an incorrect variation of ATP rules resulted in the erroneous passage of James Blake into the quarter-finals.
"The relevant rule states an incomplete match shall not count as a match played for the retiring player. This eliminated del Potro (from Group 1) based on the tiebreak procedure for greatest number of completed matches and left only Blake and Korolev tied with 1-1 records.
"Therefore, under ATP rules Korolev should have advanced having beaten Blake in their round-robin encounter.
RULE BOOK
"The same rule book prevents the ATP chairman and president or any ATP staff member from making a judgment call on the rules, as no variation can be implemented without ATP board approval.
"The rules state the final decision at a tournament rests solely with the ATP supervisor."
ATP chief executive Etienne de Villiers said: "I was contacted late at night my time and did not fully understand the issues being discussed and I made a judgment call on what seemed fair.
"However, I understand judgment calls are not part of the rule book and I must abide by the rules, as must everybody else in the circumstance."
De Villiers apologised to Blake and Korolev for all the confusion.
"This is of course an unpleasant situation...I apologize to James for giving false hope and to Evgeny. Clearly, I was wrong to intervene.
"I have always maintained we should experiment with new and different ideas and it was with this in mind I made what I thought was a fair call. I regret I got involved, that I over-ruled a supervisor and I regret this storm in a teacup."
De Villiers said the future of round-robin play has now been put on the agenda for the ATP board meeting which starts in Miami on March 22.
0
To remove first post, remove entire topic.
LAS VEGAS (Reuters) - The ATP has reversed its decision to award James Blake a quarter-final berth at the Las Vegas Open, after bending a rule to allow him through.
Russian Evgeny Korolev, who should have gone through under the rules, will now take his place in the last eight.
Needing to beat Argentine Juan Martin del Potro with the loss of no more than five games to advance on Thursday, top seed Blake was leading 6-1 3-1 when his opponent retired because of breathing problems.
Blake was then told he would not progress as the rules stated games won or lost in a walkover did not count and that Korolev would go through on a head-to-head basis after the Russian beat the American earlier in the competition.
After lengthy discussions the ATP backtracked and awarded Blake a place in the last eight, only to change its decision again on Friday.
In a statement, the ATP said "an incorrect variation of ATP rules resulted in the erroneous passage of James Blake into the quarter-finals.
"The relevant rule states an incomplete match shall not count as a match played for the retiring player. This eliminated del Potro (from Group 1) based on the tiebreak procedure for greatest number of completed matches and left only Blake and Korolev tied with 1-1 records.
"Therefore, under ATP rules Korolev should have advanced having beaten Blake in their round-robin encounter.
RULE BOOK
"The same rule book prevents the ATP chairman and president or any ATP staff member from making a judgment call on the rules, as no variation can be implemented without ATP board approval.
"The rules state the final decision at a tournament rests solely with the ATP supervisor."
ATP chief executive Etienne de Villiers said: "I was contacted late at night my time and did not fully understand the issues being discussed and I made a judgment call on what seemed fair.
"However, I understand judgment calls are not part of the rule book and I must abide by the rules, as must everybody else in the circumstance."
De Villiers apologised to Blake and Korolev for all the confusion.
"This is of course an unpleasant situation...I apologize to James for giving false hope and to Evgeny. Clearly, I was wrong to intervene.
"I have always maintained we should experiment with new and different ideas and it was with this in mind I made what I thought was a fair call. I regret I got involved, that I over-ruled a supervisor and I regret this storm in a teacup."
De Villiers said the future of round-robin play has now been put on the agenda for the ATP board meeting which starts in Miami on March 22.
If you choose to make use of any information on this website including online sports betting services from any websites that may be featured on
this website, we strongly recommend that you carefully check your local laws before doing so.It is your sole responsibility to understand your local laws and observe them strictly.Covers does not provide
any advice or guidance as to the legality of online sports betting or other online gambling activities within your jurisdiction and you are responsible for complying with laws that are applicable to you in
your relevant locality.Covers disclaims all liability associated with your use of this website and use of any information contained on it.As a condition of using this website, you agree to hold the owner
of this website harmless from any claims arising from your use of any services on any third party website that may be featured by Covers.