if this was the phillies rotation they probably would've won

Question

LeeHappPedroLeeHamelsHappLeePedro can only pitch once and hamels is not deserving of 2 an Happ is almost as good as lee.

gameto11 · Answer

LeeHappPedroLeeHamelsHappLeePedro can only pitch once and hamels is not deserving of 2 an Happ is almost as good as lee.

Sparky10191 · Answer

Hindsight is 20/20 isn&#x27;t it?&#xD;&#xA; &#xD;&#xA;Interesting how you choose to leave Pedro out of his 2nd start AFTER you saw he stunk it up.

gameto11 · Answer

no if i were the manager this wouldve been the rotation i put out there.. pedro has a history of needing 10 days rest.. this isnt hindsight 20/20

im not saying they wouldve WON with this but i think its a better rotation.. u agree?

DTher85 · Answer

Before the series even started I said Lee needs to start at least 3 games to give the Phillies a chance and some Philly fans were disagreeing with me and tried telling me their rotation was too deep that they don't need him to make 3 starts. So much for that...

JackSmack · Answer

Yea what HAPP-ened? The guy was great in the season, sometimes simply dominant, then you ditch him for Pedro talk about damaging a rookies confidence.

I mean im all for Pedro getting some starts, but why all the sudden did they not like Happ as a starter?

Sparky10191 · Answer

&#xD;&#xA;Well I can&#x27;t say Pedro has a "history" of needing 10 days rest. I do agree that Happ should have started and Lee should have gone 3 games. I&#x27;m just saying it&#x27;s easy to think about these things AFTER they lose.

peepeedik09 · Answer

Charlie M got schooled by Girardi....taken to the woodshed and beat down, Charlie M looked like he had better places to be... He knew it didn&#x27;t matter who he threw out there, except for Lee, who was to box to pitch on 3 days rest....???????????

Sparky10191 · Answer

Charlie Manuel Managed This World Series Very...VERY Poorly.

Happ should have been a starter and should have started in Game 2. (I said that from the start).

If you would like to think in hindsight, then obviously Hamels wouldn't be in the rotation but I had him in there over Blanton.

Finally...Lee should have pitched Games 1, 4 and 7.

He got too confident for no reason and blew any chance he may have had to win this thing.

interestingman · Answer

&#xD;&#xA; &#xD;&#xA;Great post. Philly was outclassed in the manager dept.

jsab · Answer

Manuel is one of those stubborn,loyal to a fault guys and it may have cost us but was certainly not overwhelmed by Girardi.

DaRaiders · Answer

Is Charlie Manuel related to Porkey Pig?

DOVJAK · Answer

what next

ManassaMauler · Answer

Happ should have been in there for sure.

jmb9 · Answer

Happ is almost as good as lee?

gameto11 · Answer

happ is almost as good as lee. yea i stand by that comment.. check his stats.

I wouldn't say girardi is a smart manager per say.. after all he sat the world series MVP 3 GAMES in philly when he easily couldve played right field.. LOL!!

but as a phillies fan i am surprised that pedro got 2 games and blanton got one as well.. i stand by the rotation i posted.

if this was the phillies rotation they probably would've won

Hot Forum Topics