Quote Originally Posted by mattbrot:
So what are we discussing here?
- if the discussion is that Harrison deserves to be punished than the answer is without question yes. There is a rule in place and he broke the rule. There is no question about that. If you have an issue with the harshness of the fine than that is fine but it can not be argued that he broke a rule (that he has done other times as well). If this is the discussion than all of the links you posted with former players and helmet hits etc. are completely irrelevant. This is a new rule that was not in place back then.
- if the discussion is about whether or not the rule is good and is leading to a softer league than that is a completely different argument.
Yeah I guess he broke a rule. And yes I believe the punishment was too harsh.
How about this: They need to change the rule. If a defender is rushing the passer and the passer is stationary, you cannot hit him in the head. On the other hand, if the QB is running with the ball and not stationary, it is simply too difficult many times to avoid contact with the helmet, and therefore should be allowed. Harrison is not 5'1". He did not launch himself into McCoy's helmet. He did not make a conscious decision to hit him in the head. McCoy was moving towards the line of scrimmage, and it's 92's job to stop him for no gain. He could have went low on him, and took out his knees, but who wants that?
There was nothing wrong with ANY of the hits that Harrison was fined for last year. You could argue that the hit on Brees might have warranted a flag, but not a fine. Absolutely not.
The purpose of the video links was just to prove that Ronnie Lot and everyone else that's ever played tackles just like Harrison does. Helmet contact is simply too difficult to avoid. It always has been and always will be. In the future there will be too many fines and too many suspensions. Ryan Clark got fined 40K for a hit on Baltimore's TE because he was defensless. 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZSIXCdBd6o
I really can't understand this one. And his helmet barely grazed the other's helmet. The call on the field was unnecessary roughness and hitting a defenseless receiver. Wow. Baltimore went on to kick a FG on that drive and the Steelers lost by a FG in a very important divisional game. This will have playoff implications, and there was absolutely nothing wrong with that hit.
The NFL needs to change the rules. But I'm sure they wont, so it is what it is I guess.
Consistency is another problem. Not sure why this wasn't deemed illegal on the field...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nVrNoK5Ab_E
No flag 
Ngata broke Roethlisberger's nose while in the pocket. The refs told Ben that Ngata was simply trying to make a tackle. Hence there was no flag thrown.
But James Harrison is a terrible person, and Ngata is not. Neither is McClain. 
No double standard there. And the point is simply this. Harrison plays hard. So does everyone else. HITS TO THE HELMET WILL CONTINUE TO HAPPEN. IT'S PART OF THE GAME, AND THAT WILL NEVER CHANGE. Players cannot avoid it. However the NFL has it out for Harrison, and the next time he hits someone very hard, he will get suspended again. And it doesn't even matter if there is helmet contact. If the QB releases the ball 1/10 of a second before he is hit, he will get suspended. If the receiver is trying to make a catch on a huge third down late in the game, and Harrison hits him too hard, he will get suspended. Because you just cannot hit hard in today's game. The purpose is to cause a fumble, or to keep the WR from making the catch, but this is a different game today. The NFL wants scoring. So he really does just need to retire. He and people like him have no place in today's game. There are many players from the 60's and 70's that would have the same problem. They would have to retire as well.