Sarah Phillips saga: Covers.com's reaction

If you own a computer, have access to the Internet and like sports, chances are you’ve seen Deadspin’s story about ESPN columnist and former Covers freelancer Sarah Phillips.

Story has been blowing up on Twitter for the past 24 hours and seemingly everyone in the mainstream sports media and beyond is chiming in, including SI’s Jimmy Traina, CBS’s Gregg Doyel and a host of others lining up to take their shots at their Disney-owned competitor and self-proclaimed worldwide leader in sports, ESPN.  

It’s a 5,400-word opus that might take you a full half of an NBA playoff game to get through and maybe longer still to digest the whole, bizarre tale. And though I discussed Phillips openly and honestly with Deadspin writer John Koblin during two interviews, I thought I’d provide this column to address the situation.

Early on in the piece you read that Phillips began her rapid rise to the ranks of ESPN Page 2 writers (now Playbook) after writing for Covers, where ESPN editor Lynn Hoppes discovered her and scooped her up in the fall of 2011 to write for ESPN.com.

By that point, Sarah had only been writing with us for a few months on a freelance basis. We initially reached out to her to write for us on a freelance basis in April of 2011 after she had developed a following on Covers through forum posts and blogs she had written. I, and one of our associate editors, had discussions with her separately over the phone and via email, during which we asked her about herself, quizzed her on sports and betting, and discussed some different content strategies.

She wrote her first column for us in early April of last year.

During the months that followed, questions arose about Sarah’s validity as a real person each time one of her columns was published. We addressed this with her on multiple occasions via phone and email conversations.

Sarah adamantly maintained that she was who she’d told us she was and our information supported that.

“I actually have always understood the skepticism of the readers on Covers,” she wrote to me in an email on April 19 of last year. “Most gamblers are irrational conspiracy theorists. These a-holes feel every sports game they lose is rigged by a conspiracy---a bunch of conspiracy theorists in one place will lead to this type of reaction. 

“Covers has access to my (verified sportsbook) account for blog deposits, you've called me, you've e-mailed me, and you have my mailing address---and I still am being questioned on the authenticity of my identity. Where does it end? “

Through all the skepticism, there was never any reliable, definitive evidence that undoubtedly proved to us she was a made up person, concocted out of thin air. And when ESPN swooped in during the summer of last year, it pretty much removed any lingering doubts. We were never contacted by ESPN at the time or ever to discuss Sarah.

Ironically, with the publication of the Deadspin story we now have more evidence than ever that she is in fact, Sarah Phillips, 22-year-old Oregonian sports fanatic. Larry Brown Sports wrote this piece today about her, supporting that claim and Koblin’s story also listed detailed personal information about Sarah Phillips. 

I emailed Sarah today and gave her the opportunity to clear the air with anything and to give her the opportunity to tell her side of the story if there’s anything she wanted to say.

“I set the record straight on my Twitter account yesterday,” she told me.

So I have to go with what we know:

•    We contracted Sarah Phillips, Oregonian sports fan and then college student to write for Covers about her experiences in sports betting and life in April of last year. That’s what she submitted to Covers on a weekly basis.

•    All the evidence continues to point to Sarah Phillips being real, which is what she vehemently maintained on all along. 

•    We parted ways with Sarah in early December of 2011. Her last column was written Dec. 6.

•    Covers editorial staff has never been involved with any of the alleged scams outlined in the Deadspin article, nor any other scams being alleged involving Sarah Phillips.

•    We at Covers have nothing to hide. Deadspin writer John Koblin told me during our last phone conversation that I had been the only one during the course of his reporting for this story who was open and immediately forthcoming from the time he first contacted us. 

Jon Campbell is the managing editor for Covers.com. Follow us on Twitter @CoversSports.

If you have any feedback or suggestions for our Editorial Team, please contact us at Editorial

            share   SHARE   rss   RSS FEED   email   EMAIL   print   PRINT
Hide All Responses
avatar

Posted by DavidGurney
1 year ago

We have a President who cannot pass E-Verify,and whose documentation would go to zero if they were placed on Intrade,but this is the fraud with which we're concerned?
avatar

Posted by PokeSmot13
1 year ago

you are on the wrong website. This isn't Alex Jones' prison planet
avatar

Posted by PokeSmot13
1 year ago

I heard she's getting a reality tv show. It's called don't trust the B---- in Apt G103
avatar

Posted by Iw1nBets
1 year ago

and her butthole didnt even taste good.. it tasted like shit
avatar

Posted by amare716
1 year ago

Wow! I was in love with Ivy Smith this whole time!
avatar

Posted by sportschat
1 year ago

it seems that many covers members had her/him/it pegged correctly from day one. It's a mystery espn, covers etc couldn't. Hell has a special place for assholes like this...
avatar

Posted by nosepickgames
1 year ago

I remember the Sarah thing last nba playoffs, it called everyone a betting loser, I got into it with it once, guys stood up for it,....so gullible...and I remember saying to ignore it and it will go away.....tout all the way....haha to all u guys who went with its picks.
avatar

Posted by yankees1913
1 year ago

If you send someone money over the phone that you have never met in person, I do not really feel sorry for you. If you do not put in your own capping and lose money following that person I do not feel sorry for you. Unless it's a family member or a best friend if someone asks for money over the phone that you never met for a bet that she placed on your behalf and your dumb enough to send your hard earned cash, oh well.
avatar

Posted by OCALSPORTS
1 year ago

"SJPHI robbed me of $600 for supposed advertising she was going to do for me on here bs website."
avatar

Posted by Laroja
1 year ago

Who the fuck cares about that broad. Why is this even on Covers' headlines LOL.
avatar

Posted by Dogjimbo
1 year ago

Well said!
avatar

Posted by DuckofDeath
1 year ago

I think that it is funny how "Covers" is trying to appear so innocent in this whole thing. But, I can't help but remember the Sarah J. craze that took over this website and how fast covers was to try and capitalize on this members popularity. To me, it seemed all very unreal, with in weeks this person (Sarah) comes on to this forum, and with a very snobish attitude basically is given a key to the website. At one point, I almost thought that this profile was perpetrated by the covers staff themselves.
avatar

Posted by j_hedon
1 year ago

wow a good looking broad/journalist who lies and now countless articles from lying journalists lying to cover their knowledge of employing a liar. good thing there aren't too many of those kinds of people around. what a society.
avatar

Posted by _keyser_soze_
1 year ago

I don't care whether there is a girl named Sarah Phillips who you spoke with on the phone or the internet, the FACT is - she's a con artist (or works for one) and the countless people (myself included) who tried to point out her many lies were threatened with banishment if we didn't shut the hell up by people at Covers. Keep trying to make yourself look good for getting the wool pulled over your eyes. You employed a con artist, and now you're trying to spin it so you don't look bad. Too late.
avatar

Posted by The Hawk
1 year ago

Have you EVER, in YOUR LIFE, ever heard of a woman that DID NOT want to be on TELEVISION to explain her side? Jon, you used so many words without saying anything, you should be a lawyer. At minimum, you and the rest of the Covers braintrust, should reinstate the people you kicked out, and give them $100 in BetJam funny money........
avatar

Posted by FoolishTool
1 year ago

NASTY NASTY BITCH!!!!!!! someone ought to stomp the shiit out of her then stomp the shiit out of her parents!!!!!
avatar

Posted by FoolishTool
1 year ago

,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, and the stupid bastard that got used ought to has his ass beat also for letting it happen!!!!! fkn dunce!!!!
avatar

Posted by 222bad
1 year ago

KInd of nice not having to put up with SJP and covers.com constantly supporting her charade. Why after all this time does this even seem relevant to anyone that has anything to say about the inner workings of this site. Why beat a dead horse, just let it die with dignity. Oh shit, I forgot, she had none, and probably never will.
avatar

Posted by TheTotalHunter
1 year ago

It's some touts girlfriend that is playing along. She is real I have no doubt, but she is a puppet for a tout.
avatar

Posted by alling
1 year ago

Follow her picks and fade them. Her picks/units record are one of the worse on the internet.
avatar

Posted by TMAN100
1 year ago

Why anyone gets upset when they take someone else's picks is beyond me. Just tell that to the guys that make the lines. I read her columns once in a while for the entertainment value, and have wondered until now where she went. Do your own work and make your own choices. Then you have no one to blame.
avatar

Posted by toddwins
1 year ago

All of this can be easily solved by her. All she has to do is take a picture of herself holding a "Covers" sign in her hand.
avatar

Posted by Vesco
1 year ago

The Bitch isn't real man... We live in the digital, internet age! Respect that fact!!
avatar

Posted by Gbobgunn
1 year ago

The Greatest trick the Devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn't exist
avatar

Posted by toddwins
1 year ago

Keyser Soze
         1   2    next page    last page
You are currently not logged in.
Login | Signup | Help
You must be logged in to post a comment.

Top Response

Posted by vegasdennis
1 year ago

"I will take Kaponos question one step further. If covers didn't know how come when user Jmon posted he had proof who she was. He was immediately banned and every post of his mysteriously deleted "