Cram Session: Something’s wrong with NCAA Tournament odds

Duke remains the favorite to win national championship. WTF?

The defending champion Blue Devils at +300 sit atop the Las Vegas Hilton’s odds to win the NCAA Men’s Basketball Tournament. Top-ranked and undefeated Ohio State is next at +400, followed by Kansas (+600) and Texas (+800).

A lot of offshore sportsbooks don’t have NCAA Tournament odds up. I first found some at Sportsbook.com Tuesday, but thought they were outdated when I saw Duke favored. Then, the good guys at the Hilton sent me their numbers Wednesday and confirmed that it was not a mistake – in some oddsmakers’ eyes, Duke is still the team to beat.

I repeat: WTF?

Ohio State, Kansas and Texas are better than Duke, right? I don’t think I’m throwing shocking news out there by writing that.

Las Vegas oddsmaker Pete Korner of the Sports Club says the Buckeyes would be 4-point favorites over Duke on a neutral floor. The Jayhawks would be 2.5-point favorites over the Blue Devils and a Duke-Texas game would a pick ‘em, according to Korner.

The power ratings I looked at, including Pomeroy, Sagarin, Massey and Covers Expert Nick Parsons’, all have Ohio State and Kansas rated ahead of Duke. Only one, Sagarin’s Predictor, has the Blue Devils ahead of Texas. So I’m not the only one that thinks Duke is a second-tier team.

Of course, Mike Krzyzewski disagrees.

"The team we played tonight can play with anybody, and we're getting to the point where we might be able to play with anybody," Krzyzewski told reporters after Wednesday’s comeback win over North Carolina. “Going forward, both teams will have a chance to cause trouble for some people."

The reaction was mixed after the Blue Devils came from 16 points down to knock off the Tar Heels. I downgrade Duke more for falling behind to an improving, but far from elite North Carolina team than I credit Coach K’s team for pulling it out in the second half. That’s not happening against a team with a more experienced backcourt, like say St. John’s, for example. The Red Storm annihilated Duke 93-78 in late January.

The Devils aren’t getting any bulkier down low by March, either. If North Carolina’s Tyler Zeller and John Henson had their way against Duke’s interior defense, think about what Ohio State’s Jared Sullinger or Kansas’ Morris twins would do.

A good NCAA Tournament draw could mask some of Duke’s flaws, but let’s not just automatically hand the defending champs a No. 1 seed. Some of Duke’s impressive non-conference wins don’t look as impressive now that Michigan State and Kansas State have imploded. And winning the ACC isn’t nearly the accomplishment it used to be.

The wildcard in all this Kyrie Irving, the Blue Devils’ stud freshman point guard who has been out since early December with a toe injury. Irving got the cast off his right foot last week, generating some speculation that he might return this season. But Krzyzewski has repeatedly said that Irving will not be back this year.

If Coach K is playing coy and Irving returns, I’ll re-assess, but right now Duke doesn’t look like the favorite to win the national title to me, despite what some oddsmakers suggest.

Player of the Year Odds

Bodog.com has been Jimmered.

The offshore sportsbook posted BYU star Jimmer Fredette as a +125 (5/4) favori

If you have any feedback or suggestions for our Editorial Team, please contact us at Editorial

            share   SHARE   rss   RSS FEED   email   EMAIL   print   PRINT
Hide All Responses
avatar

Posted by YieldSread
2 years ago

Exactly, well stated.
avatar

Posted by YieldSread
2 years ago

Exactly, well stated.
avatar

Posted by Mikado
2 years ago

Duke is favored for many reasons. Last year they had arguably one of the easiest roads to the final four. This is because Duke is a complete mismatch to most college team outside the major conferences. The coaching speaks for itself. Coach K always seems to pull out the close ones. They aren't a covering machine, but when playing teams with a good defense for the pick and roll (Like UNC, FSU, and SJU) they will be constantly challenged. I think David Payne nailed it, Seth Curry and how he comes along in tournament time will be interesting to see. Especially if he starts to develop into the type of shooter as his brother Steph... Duke will be a very dangerous team in the tournament.
avatar

Posted by David_Payne
2 years ago

@LasVegasFinest -- Agreed, it's hard to go against Coach K. With that said, he's not going to be able to coach his guys to get bigger on the inside or more athletic on the outside. Seth Curry's development will be key. Ohio State doesn't give up easy baskets, commit among the fewest fouls. I'll take the Buckeyes at +400.
avatar

Posted by lasvegasfinest1
2 years ago

ohio st is not the best team in the contry. they cant score with teams like duke and kansas. i agree that RIGHT NOW knsas and texas may be better than duke. but right now doesnt matter. last year you could name 4 or even 5 teams better than duke but they cut down the nets. college bball is all about gearing for the tourney. some teams peek in dec/januray(syracuse,uconn) for example. other teams progressively get better and search for that perfect lineup. and thats why they have duke favored. because no one gets more out of there players in tourney time than COACH K.
         1      
You are currently not logged in.
Login | Signup | Help
You must be logged in to post a comment.

Top Response

Posted by YieldSread
2 years ago

"Exactly, well stated."