More answers to questions about the Donaghy scandal

There are more questions than answers following NBA commissioner David Stern’s press conference Tuesday about the Tim Donaghy officiating scandal. A pile of good ones have come our way here in the Covers.com newsroom and we’ve been poring over our exclusive referee statistics in search of clues.

Here are some of the key questions and the answers based on our research so far.

Is it possible to tell with certainty whether Donaghy was involved in fixing games based on the numbers alone?

Short answer: no. There are some intriguing trends that raise some questions but they don’t come close to proving anything on their own. I noted some of them in my column on Tuesday. The truth is there are a lot of officials who have disproportional trends in their stats but it doesn’t mean they’ve done anything wrong according to NBA rules.

Have you found any other numbers worth noting since Tuesday?

Yes. But again they don’t prove anything standing on their own. If you’re interested, here’s what we found: 

- In each of the past two seasons, Donaghy has been among the top six NBA officials with the most disproportional average points per game compared to the average over/under line in his games. In 2006-07, the games in which he officiated saw an average of 201.2 points per game compared to an average over/under of 196.26 in those games – a difference of 4.94 points. That ranks as the fourth-most disproportional in the NBA. The year before, he had a difference of 4.66 points which ranked sixth. To see more, click on this chart.

- The average differential for all referees for the 2006-07 season was 2.07 points.

- Here is the over-to-under record for Donaghy’s games over the past four seasons in games in which his crew called more than 50 fouls: 2006-07: 13-4-1; 2005-06: 27-7; 2004-05: 12-11-1; 2003-04: 10-9; 2002-03: 10-5-1; 2001-02: 5-2

- Since the 2004-05 season, Donaghy has gone from averaging 193.72 points per game in the games his crews officiated to 201.2 points in the 2006-07 season. Has he had significant jumps like this before? Yes. He averaged 193.55 points in the 2002-03 season and then averaged more than seven points fewer in 2003-04 with 184.14.

Have other officials had jumps in points per game from one season to another similar to Donaghy's?

It happens all the time. Tony Nunez Jr. is one of many examples. Just last year he made an incredible jump of 11.7 points from the season before. In 2006-2007, his crews averaged 202.4 points per game compared to 190.7 points from the 2005-06 season. This is part of a general pattern of inconsistency with NBA officiating.  

In your opinion, would it be easier to try to fix pointspreads or over/unders?

I’d say over/unders (or totals) would be easier to try to fix on the floor. You would do that by calling fouls in certain situations and you could do it without showing as much bias as you would if you were trying to get one team to cover the spread against another.

Here’s the catch and it's a big one: You would make far less money betting on totals than you would betting on spreads, which longtime oddsmaker Keith Glantz reminded me of yesterday. Almost all books – legal or illegal – have significantly lower limits on over/under bets than they do on pointspreads for the very reason that totals are easier to fix. So if we’re talking about a really greedy group of people here, rigging pointspreads would be far more enticing than rigging totals.

Should the NBA have picked up on this sooner?

Based on the numbers, there’s nothing

If you have any feedback or suggestions for our Editorial Team, please contact us at Editorial

            share   SHARE   rss   RSS FEED   email   EMAIL   print   PRINT
Hide All Responses
avatar

Posted by closeedge
5 years ago

nba sucks
avatar

Posted by Miracle
5 years ago

Donaghy definitely is NOT the first official to fix games. NBA is a garbage league anyway, the refs have way too much influence in the outcome.
avatar

Posted by professorkopak
5 years ago

THERE ARE OVER 1200 GAMES IN THE NBA. OIT IS UNLIKELY THAT THIS REFEREE ATTEMPTED TO IX MORE THAN A DOZEN. HE LIKELY FIXED THE TOTALS. OF COURSE LOSERS WILL TELL YOU THAT MANY GAMES ARE FIXED. IDOUBT THAT THERE IS ANOTHER REFEREE FIXING GAMES. IF HE FIXED 12 TOTALS YOU WOULD STILL WOULD LIKELY BE ON WINNING SIDE IN HALF THOSE. A BETTOR AT WORST WOULD BE ON WRONG SIDE 1/2 OF THE TIME. I READ COMMENTS THAT ARE NOT RATIONAL AND I IMMEDIATELY KNOW THEY LOSE.
avatar

Posted by styo
5 years ago

THERE HAS BEEN A BLACK CLOUD OVER THE NBA FOR MANY,MANY YEARS !!
avatar

Posted by par101
5 years ago

how can anyone trust the NBA again? its a sham
avatar

Posted by stockopt21
5 years ago

I love how all of a sudden this is becoming reality. For years I've said the NBA is the biggest scam going. I think the only way that league still remains intact is due to gambling. All the major networks dropped them years ago because NO ONE was watching. So TNT and ESPN scooped the league up for a cheap broadcast of sports. As "JDOG" said above, what is the likelihood that out of a slate of 10 games on a given night you can find about half of the spreads or totals within a half a point or a push. That just doesn't happen. The oddsmakers aren't THAT good. It's no mistake. If a team is blowing someone out, the refs blow the whistles the other way to cover the 12 point Phoenix is giving to the grizzlies. It always comes down to that final meaningless 3-pointer or layup that ruins your day.
avatar

Posted by chmyer
5 years ago

This is why you fade the public. If a game is going to be fixed organizations like the Mafia will tend to benefit if the public gets screwed so they can line their pockets. I realize this is a rather large generalization considering less than 1% of games are likely fixed but I thought I'd throw it out there.
avatar

Posted by vtec626
5 years ago

man...no wonder i was getting alot of bad beats in the NBA last year. where do i go to get my money back?
avatar

Posted by games1
5 years ago

this stuff goes on all of the time...it ism't the first nor will it be the last.....
avatar

Posted by jdog1714
5 years ago

It is hard to prove he fixed some of the games. Most of the stuff I read talked about over & under are easier to fix than point spread. It could be true, but we have to keep one thing in mind, and that is Vegas offers half time line, full game and quarters. Referee can fix any game pretty much at will, as long as he knows what the point spreads and totals are for that game. He can fix the first , second half, or any quarter. If Tim Donaghy doesn't talk about how he fixed it, we won't know for sure. Did anyone wonder why some of the game results are so close to the point spread or total line? Is Tim Donaghy the only person in the NBA league (players, referee, coaches & owners etc) into gambling?
avatar

Posted by ChAoSoRb
5 years ago

can't prove he fixed games... only looming doubts... nba will come out say oh he just gambled everything is fine nothing is rigged and move on...
         1      
You are currently not logged in.
Login | Signup | Help
You must be logged in to post a comment.

Top Response

Posted by styo
5 years ago

"THERE HAS BEEN A BLACK CLOUD OVER THE NBA FOR MANY,MANY YEARS !!"