Monday night debate: Who's the better QB, Brady or Brees?

There are enough storylines in Monday's big game to keep a room full of writers busy for months. We grabbed two of the lesser talented ones and got them to go over some of the main points bettors are talking about.

Who is the better quarterback right now: Tom Brady or Drew Brees?

Grewal: Brady is playing awfully good right now. He's shaken off the rust he was showing at the start of the season, and his offensive line is giving him all kinds of time.

I'm still going to go with Brees. For all the stats that Brady has the edge in, Brees has the most important one: wins.

Carey: Tom Brady. Period. The three-time Super Bowl Champion has about 300 more yards but only two fewer touchdown passes and three fewer interceptions, all while averaging nearly seven more pass attempts per game than Brees. The New England offense is much more reliant on Brady – the Patriots average about 40 fewer rushing yards per game and has scored seven less rushing touchdowns – plus the team plays in cold weather, not a dome.

Brees is slightly more explosive, but don’t let ESPN highlight packages fool you, Brady still is the best, even if the donkeys on “Around the Horn” are sick of talking about him.

Is this game more important to the Saints or the Pats?

Carey: The Saints need this game more. New Orleans is undefeated, but leads the Vikings by a mere game for the top seed in the NFC. The Saints playing at home in the Superdome is key to a successful playoff run. Meantime, New England has the Little Sisters of the Poor to beat up on in the AFC East, and likely won’t face another potential playoff team until Week 16 or 17. The Saints being favored by a single point shows they have a slight edge at home and the books believe they want this game more.

Grewal: Gotta agree with that. This isn't just about the overall standings in the NFC and it's not about continuing an undefeating season.

All of New Orleans' big wins this season don't look so big anymore. This is a statement game for the Saints. If they don't win this one, we'll all be questioning how good Sean Payton's boys really are.

Will either defense show up and make some stops?

Grewal: The Pats and the Saints get out to big leads just about every week, which means each team's secondary is tested every Sunday.

I'm a little worried about all wounded defensive backs New Orleans has but I think you'll see some stops and maybe even a few three-and-outs.

Carey: Fans of low-scoring, ball control, grinding games should stay away from this matchup which features a total of 56.5. If either defense steps up, look for it to be the Saints.

The team’s secondary has been hit hard by injuries, but New Orleans still has a league-high 20 interceptions and allowed a meager nine touchdown passes, the third-fewest in the league.

New England should do a few things early to confuse Brees, but by the middle of the fourth quarter, it will become obvious that whoever has the ball last will win.

Final score predictions

Carey: New England 38, New Orleans 35

Grewal: New England 28, New Orleans 24

            share   SHARE   rss   RSS FEED   email   EMAIL   print   PRINT
Advertisement
avatar

Posted by kixmix
3 months ago

typo mistake.. under sounds alright. total would be about around 45-50. 23-20 N.O. saints.
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by kixmix
3 months ago

saints wins in a tight game! under sonds alright.
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by illestnoise
3 months ago

N.E. +1.5 and UNDER 56.5 PARLAY how much you win for $3.00
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by madh4ttr
3 months ago

Monday Night Play is: N.E. +1.5 and UNDER 56.5 PARLAY
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by WinsNow999
3 months ago

Under dog & Under. New England 27 New Orleans 24 Odds = NO -2 / 56
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by just_average
3 months ago

I just don't see this game low scoring. This is what these two teams do! I think the offense makes big yardage plays ton on both sides. Yes the Defense's will step up on both teams but on a monday night in the dome??,... im calling the numbers to reach high 30's into 40's. Watch out for special teams plays also
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by potxroastx42o
3 months ago

patriots learn from there last mistake they will win they're not gonna let this one slip by.
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by imjust2gud
3 months ago

57.5 is the total i seen now...If i get 58 I'm hammering the Under...It's much harder to score in the NFL than it is not to...So if one of the 2 qb's is a little off, or If the Saints run the ball much like I expect them to...A 17-14 game at halftime wont doom me in...
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by drewpy24
3 months ago

saints over parlay?
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by botk
3 months ago

Line open at -3 the public is on New England that why the line is at -1. New Orleans 20 INT is the best in the NFL. New Orleans 38 New England 28
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by VNAM777
3 months ago

OVER OVER OVER OVER OVER
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by JMon
3 months ago

This game is going under.. Inflated total line due to hype of two high powered offenses. Because the hype of this game..both defenses will come out and play. Special teams and defenses will out shine the QB's in this game. Stress free...bet the under and watch the game.
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by drewpy24
3 months ago

Im thinking over 56.5 because all Monday nights have gone under the last 3 weeks
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by BoutTime
3 months ago

Wouldn't a "slight" edge be more of a -3 at Home? I mean, that is what the home team gives when all else is equal. The books are telling you that NE has the slight edge here. Also, the Saints haven't faced a decent team in how long? New England has been in this big spot how many times? How many times have the Saints been in a big spot and won? Edge goes to NE here if you ask me. Also will wait to see how much "Shoot-out" talk I hear, and might take the Under, especially w/an Over on Sunday night, that to me, SCREAMED Under. S H I T T Y Pitt defense down the stretch killed that........ Just my thoughts. BOL
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by bilsfn15
3 months ago

Pats win this game...they should have beat the Colts...they wont make the same mistake
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by DDH420
3 months ago

I'll take 3 rings for my house Alex.
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by JB13372
3 months ago

Over/Under I have no clue.....
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
avatar

Posted by JB13372
3 months ago

Oh my god...I was thinking that out of the two, one of them would have been right! The Saints will win by 4. 27-23...or something like that! Trust me...if you ever will...Orleans (-1) all day long.
comment   SEND PM   comment   ADD TO FRIENDS                     (+0)     (-0)
1
You are currently not logged in.
You must be logged in to post a comment.

Top Response

Posted by potxroastx42o
3 months ago

"patriots learn from there last mistake they will win they're not gonna let this one slip by."

Sports Betting Headlines »
Game: Minnesota @ Purdue
Start Time: 3/13/2010 4:05:00 PM
Handicapper: David Malinsky
Pick: under
Analysis:  
   
4* #532 PURDUE/MINNESOTA Under (4:05 Eastern) Looking for a smooth and fluid basketball flow, with teams running up and down the floor and finding easy scoring opportunities? Turn the channel. This one is going to look like two teams trying to run their fast breaks in wet cement before it dries, and in a game that will feature neither high offensive efficiency or pace, the oddsmakers are offering plenty of cushion for this se...
read more »
More Free Picks