Ted Sevransky

Is Jay Cutler the NFL's most overrated QB?

By TED SEVRANSKY - Direct From Vegas: Sports Investing for long term profits
October 26, 2009   14 comments
send to a friend print version rss feeds AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Teddy spends every Sunday typing furiously at his laptop as he watches the games, giving you the key info that the box scores and game recaps simply don’t have. This week: NFC tidbits from around the league.

Chicago Bears

Has there ever been an NFL quarterback with more hype and less production than Jay Cutler? Cutler didn't do anything in college – remember Vandy didn't end its bowl drought until after he graduated.

In the NFL he was QB of the team that engineered a record setting collapse last year; blowing a three-game division lead with three games to play. Here in Chicago, the Bears have beaten Seattle without Matt Hasselbeck, the hapless Lions and Pittsburgh in a game where Jeff Reed (the Steelers kicker) pulled a complete choke job.

Meanwhile, Denver has been the best team in the AFC this side of Indy now that Cutler is out of town. What the hell is so good about Jay Cutler? Once again, I'll make the comparison to Jeff George, another QB with great tangibles and lousy intangibles.

Back to the game notes…

Chicago’s defense is getting torched on the perimeter. The unit is unable to stop the run or the pass. The Bears allowed nearly 300 yards of offense in the first half; giving up five scores on five drives; forcing only two incomplete passes and allowing more than five yards per carry.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

I think this team is worse than the Rams putting the club right at the absolute bottom of the NFL. There isn't a single above average unit on the squad -- quarterback, offensive line, running backs, receivers, defensive line, linebackers, secondary, special teams or coaching.

QB Josh Johnson has some scrambling ability and he can fire downfield, but accuracy is certainly not one of his strengths at this stage of his young career.

Dallas Cowboys

This offense continues to show home run potential on a weekly basis; a big play waiting to happen. Even though WR Roy Williams has been a complete bust since coming to Dallas, undrafted Miles Austin has developed into a home-run threat at the other wideout spot. When Romo is on, this has the potential to be an elite level offense.

And we saw an impressive showing from the Cowboys defense once again. This stop unit has been top notch in every game this season. They owned the line of scrimmage in this one, despite another rash of offside penalties.

San Francisco 49ers

Michael Crabtree played. Frank Gore played. They both looked good, with Crabtree, in particular, making a couple of beautiful catches in his first NFL game. This offense still stinks with Shawn Hill at quarterback. San Fran gained a total of 30 yards on its first 15 plays.

But this was a completely different looking offense in the second half. The receivers spread the field and ran vertical routes, not dink-and-dunk like they were doing with Hill behind center. All of a sudden, this was a big play, downfield attack with Crabtree, Isaac Bruce, Josh Morgan and Vernon Davis all making plays downfield, and Alex Smith putting the ball right in their hands.

Without a doubt, that's the best offensive half of football that we've seen from the 49ers in the entire Mike Singletary era.

Carolina Panthers

Jake Delhomme seems to be regressing on a weekly basis. He’s under throwing and overthrowing wide open receivers, making wrong reads, throwing to the wrong guy, taking delay of game penalties – the works. The coaching staff doesn't trust him to throw downfield and his receivers don't trust him to hit them downfield.

The running game can pick up yardage in chunks, but no NFL team can win games consistently without some semblance of a passing game. Carolina can win the time of possession battle and the yardage battle all they want to -- unless they score touchdowns, they're not going back to the playoffs.

New Orleans Saints

We saw proof that Drew Brees and the Saints offense can be stopped....for a half. In the first half, Brees took hits, sacks, he threw interceptions, he held the ball too long and he made bad decisions under pressure. In the second half, buoyed by the running of Mike Bell, Brees proved that he is an elite level QB, rallying back from repeated mistakes and overcoming a three-touchdown deficit.
This could easily have been throwaway game for New Orleans. Instead, the squad’s second half performance was nothing short of extraordinary, against a physical team on a grass field away from home.

Minnesota Vikings

Minnesota was able to mask the loss of star cornerback Antoine Winfield here, thanks to a fierce pass rush and an impressive overall effort from the secondary. Minny didn't allow a completion longer than 10 yards until the two minute drill and only allowed two completions of longer than 10 yards all day.

Last time the Vikes went on the road, they were sloppy early at St Louis. This time, they were sloppy throughout and the endless parade of penalties and turnovers cost them the game. On offense they had to overcome five false starts, a holding, a tripping and an illegal shift penalty.

The tripping penalty was nonsense and it cost them a touchdown. Two plays later came the sack/fumble, returned 88 yards for a touchdown the other way; the difference in the game.

14 comments
comment Post A Comment
EDDIE_ROYAL19
EDDIE_ROYAL19 says:
10/26/09 02:50PM

hillarious....I think the bears know they made a huge mistake as of this morning. guaranteeing this clown $20M??? he just can't win games. yes, he puts up stats but that because his team gets down from his many turnovers and he starts to shred defenses when his team is down 2-3 scores. but they got down from his turnovers. that is why he is ALWAYS playing from behind. the kid is not a winner and never will be. in life, he is successfull because he got paid. but in the game, he is a loser and always will be.

JUSS WANT TO THANK ALL THE BEARS EXECS for KYLE ORTON, TWO #1 PICKS AND A #3 AS THIS IS WHAT WE GOT FOR THE CRYBABY

xbixbyx
xbixbyx says:
10/26/09 03:17PM

funny. yea, he is really overrated. i still think it's funny how they ended up switching teams

bodio
bodio says:
10/26/09 04:01PM

I'm a huge Bears fan and I'm sad to say that I agree. The Bears made a huge mistake!

cubboy
cubboy says:
10/26/09 04:30PM

HE HAS NO PROTECTION....DENVER BY FAR HAS A BETTER LINE AND RECIEVERS...BUT YES HE IS MAKING SOME PISS POOR MISTAKES

JohnKreese
JohnKreese says:
10/26/09 04:31PM

He has no chin.

alling
alling says:
10/26/09 04:46PM

If he was a great QB denver never traded him. Major red flag.

nguyen7327
nguyen7327 says:
10/26/09 05:23PM

Damn Eddie ur on fire did you play 20 units? are you going to play this weekend?

DJNY
DJNY says:
10/26/09 06:01PM

I have bashed this guy as the most over rated QB since being traded to CHI. Chicago was already over rated then they bring in this clown thinking he is going to save them, but has only made them worse.

RahstahMan
RahstahMan says:
10/26/09 07:04PM

I never believed all the hype this guy received was warranted. Yes he threw for over 4500 yards last year in Denver with the 7th most TDs in the league but he also had the 2nd most INTs (18). This year he is replicating that performance with 11 TDs (8th) and 10 INTs (2nd). Add to that the fact he was 17-20 as a starter in Denver and never made the playoffs. Hell, he's never even had a winning season as a starter. He went 2-3 in the 5 games he started at the end of the '06 season, 7-9 in '07, and 8-8 in '08.

That's not to say he won't turn it around and end up having a great career but so far I don't see it.

Tyler_Reed
Tyler_Reed says:
10/26/09 11:27PM

I think the writer of this article and the rest of you who commented are severe Jacka@$$es. . .

If you watch the games you can tell this dude has no protection whatsoever. . . the offensive line doesn't even help in giving him a running game to go along to complete an offense. . . when you're number one receiver is Devin Hester - how much can you expect. Cutler has got all the talent to bring a team to dominance. A good number of his "bad decisions" are made under extreme (and immediate) pressure and he has to heave a pass up to the likes of - oh excuse me johnny knox and devin hester. . . ARE YOU SERIOUS!? The dude has a strong arm and if he had at least 2 seconds after a drop back he's as accurate as they come. I wish I was collecting your wagers because you all know nothing about the ins and outs of a football game. . .

xbixbyx
xbixbyx says:
10/27/09 02:14AM

tyler, he's overrated because he was traded for 3 guys and sports reports acted like he was the best qb ever. it doesn't matter how much talent that he may have, it's the amount of hype and drama behind him and that trade.

RahstahMan
RahstahMan says:
10/27/09 06:17AM

Tyler, Since none of us know the ins and outs of football please explain to us what his excuse(s) for, as you put it, "a good number of his bad decisions" were while he was in Denver where he had a good offensive line and B.Marshall, B.Stokely, and E.Royal to throw to? He still had weak numbers and losing seasons as it has already been pointed out.

Accurate? Last year in Denver he barely made the top half (15th) in the league in pass completion percentage. He got beat out by J.Campbell, D.Garrard, S.Hill, and M.Cassel. In 2007 he just made the top half as well at 13th. How accurate is that?

And who gives a garbage if he has a strong arm. A multitude of QBs, past and present, have/had strong arms and a propensity for losing. J.George (remember him) and J.Russell (both first round, first overall draft picks) both had/have cannons and both had/have losing records as well.

Like I said, Cutler is young and still may become a franchise QB but so far I, and many fans, haven't seen it.

In conclusion, if you won't accept reasoning perhaps you'll take a bit of advice. As one of our great leaders once stated,"It is better to remain silent and thought a fool than to speak up and remove all doubt."

RahstahMan
RahstahMan says:
10/27/09 06:24AM

"Who gives a 'garbage' if ..."

Oops, thats what I get for typing the "S" word. LOL

Actually it's pretty cool (and funny) we can't type four letter words.

:)

proptraderbklyn
proptraderbklyn says:
10/27/09 07:33AM

I would take Eli Manning over Jay Cutler

Post A Comment

Add your response:

Click here to login.
Advertisement