The great debate: Who covers in the BCS Championship?

By COVERS.com STAFF | January 7, 2009 | 17 comments
send to a friend print version rss feeds AddThis Social Bookmark Button

The BCS Championship pits the top two conferences in the land against each other for the national title.

The SEC's Florida Gators have been unstoppable since an upset loss back in September while the Big 12's Oklahoma Sooners prevailed after rolling through the toughest schedule in football.

Covers Experts' Steve Merril and the Miller Group's Sean Murphy take off the gloves and debate their picks for the BCS title game. Merril has faith in the Gators while Murphy believes in the Sooners. One thing is for certain Thursday: College football bettors are in for a treat.

Oklahoma Sooners vs. Florida Gators (-4.5, 69.5)

Sam Bradford

Murphy: The reigning Heisman Trophy winner was the nation’s best passer by a long shot this season, throwing for over 4,400 yards, 48 touchdowns and only six interceptions. His success was no fluke when you consider he threw 36 touchdowns and eight interceptions as a freshman last year. He has displayed outstanding poise in the pocket and has just enough mobility to handle the Florida pass rush. The Gators can’t afford to fall asleep at the wheel as Bradford ran for four touchdowns this season.

Big 12 failure

Merril: The Big 12 has been a major disappointment so far this bowl season, going just 2-4 ATS. Kansas and Nebraska have covered the pointspread but the higher profile teams like Missouri, Oklahoma State, Texas Tech and Texas have all underperformed and stand a combined 0-4 ATS. The most notable game was last Friday when Mississippi from the SEC thoroughly outplayed Texas Tech.

Motivation

Murphy: After getting crushed by West Virginia in last year’s Fiesta Bowl, the Sooners are hungry for redemption. With the exception of running back Allen Patrick, the majority of their offensive weapons are back and eager to erase the memory of that performance. Remember, they scored only 15 points through the first three quarters in that game. They’ll be facing a tougher test but there’s no question they’ve matured a lot since last season. Preparation will be key and this time, I think they’re ready.

SEC success

Merril: While the Big 12 has faltered, the SEC has performed extremely well so far this bowl season with a combined 5-2 ATS record. This includes outright underdog wins by four different teams as LSU, Vanderbilt, Kentucky and Mississippi all pulled the straight-up wins.

A down year for the SEC

Murphy: There’s no question it was a down year for the SEC at least by its own standards. In recent seasons it has been the pinnacle of college football conferences but that wasn’t the case this year. With LSU, Tennessee, Arkansas and Kentucky all dropping off, the Gators didn’t face the toughest path to the championship. They outlasted Alabama in the SEC title game but we all saw what happened to the Tide against Utah in the Sugar Bowl.

Injuries

Merril: Florida is getting healthy as both running back Chris Rainey and wide receiver Percy Harvin are listed as probable and expected to play. Meanwhile, Oklahoma will be without running back DeMarco Murray who is out with a hamstring injury. This is a major loss as Murray is second on the team with 1,002 rushing yards this season and averages 5.6 yards per carry with 14 rushing touchdowns.

Sooners’ tough schedule

Murphy: The Big 12 returned to prominence across all fronts in 2008. With that, the Sooners had to go though the gauntlet to get here. They faced the best the conference had to offer in Texas, Texas Tech, Oklahoma State, Kansas and Missouri. Not only that, they also penciled in a couple of tough non-conference tilts with Cincinnati and TCU, games they won handily by a combined 87-36 margin. Their only blemish was a loss to Texas but everyone is allowed one hiccup. Why don’t you ask Florida about its loss to Ole Miss.

Defense

Merril: Both teams have explosive offensive units but Florida is the much better defensive squad. The Gators allow just 12.8 points per game and only 4.4 yards per play while Oklahoma permits a much weaker 24.5 points per game and 5.1 yards per play.

Is anyone giving Oklahoma a chance?

Murphy: You’ll be hard pressed to find many Oklahoma backers heading into this game. With the books dangling out a relatively short line, the Gators are receiving a ton of love from both the betting public and sharps alike. Is it really that easy? Could we be in for a repeat of two years ago when the sheep were led to the slaughter by heavily favored Ohio State against these same Florida Gators? I guess those questions will be answered Thursday night.

Bowl records

Merril: Both head coaches have won national titles but Florida’s Urban Meyer has performed much better in recent bowl games than Oklahoma’s Bob Stoops. It has been eight years since Stoops won the national title and he is just 1-4 straight up the past five years in bowl games including losing outright as near-touchdown favorites the past two years. Meanwhile, Florida won the BCS title two years ago and overall Urban Meyer is 4-1 SU/ATS in all bowl games the past five years as the head coach of both Utah and Florida.

17 comments
comment Post A Comment
nc1capper says:
01/07/09 11:38PM

everything leans towards the gators here to be sure , my coin says it will play out that way , love the insights and hope the game lives up to the hype --keep pumpin the info out , it is appreciated

twelvepbrs says:
01/08/09 12:30AM

I love the "Sooner's Tough Schedule" point. All the tough teams listed (except Kansas) were flops in their bowls, losing as favs or winning but not covering. A lot of the "weak" teams that the Gators dominated throughout the season have been pleasant surprises during bowl season. I really think this line should be -6 or -6.5. Already on UF and the Under medium, I think I'm gonna bet the house minimum on every prop and just enjoy the show. GLA!

Blackshirt51 says:
01/08/09 02:08AM

OU FOR ME

GaryPhilly says:
01/08/09 02:36AM

I love when the entire betting world is on one side.

It makes my pick easy.

This year everyone is all over Florida.

So I'll be on Oklahoma at the apex of the line.

Best Wishes!!

1StupidHaole says:
01/08/09 03:25AM

GaryPhilly,

You should be a pro capper!!

sportychick says:
01/08/09 09:24AM

Any team that can socre 50 a game without breaking a sweat, receiivng points in a neutral staidum = Gotta like it.

KasperNV says:
01/08/09 10:40AM

Not impressed with the Big 12 at all. Gators in a romp.

ShuffleList says:
01/08/09 11:21AM

I think OU's offense is too much for FL's defense even though they say to always go for the team with the better D.

bej0101 says:
01/08/09 01:38PM

like the over 69.5....42/40..

ravens1 says:
01/08/09 01:39PM

lets go ou time for anothr one

JCWhy83 says:
01/08/09 02:16PM

goin big on OU

NMD143 says:
01/08/09 04:01PM

I am a GEORGIA DAWG and I hate Florida. That said, How can people say that Okla's offence is too much for FL? Half the QB's in that confrence threw for around 3,000 yards or more b/c there is NO defence!!! OK will be lucky to put 30 pts on the board. The question is... will the high scoring FL team show up tonight? I think they will.

FLORIDA by 10-14 OR MORE!!!

bx719 says:
01/08/09 05:41PM

ill say OU+6 sound good but no play but enjoy the game..

Skinnyboy says:
01/08/09 06:25PM

You're right NMD. I bet the DAWG can beat OU too. Look what the Gator did to Georgia. I think Georgia is similar to OU if not better. They have two top ten picks in the draft. If Stafford was playing in that conference he would've have won the Heisman too. So I say Gator all the way.

FLA-45

OU-28

sosoon says:
01/08/09 06:42PM

I've taken OK+6, usually i'm on favorite but my little finger tell me otherwise lol

GL all

:D

Tyler_Reed says:
01/08/09 08:14PM

most people are going with Florida. . .which is why the line went up so people would take Oklaholma with more points to balance out the action. . .with that being said, i think Tebow just like Harrel and McCoy will have a great offensive explosion, Harvey is the wild card as we all know, he can score two tds a game against any college defense - i see FLA 34 Okla 20

gqbossing says:
01/08/09 08:41PM

The play here is FLA -5.5, with a small play on the over at 69.5. Great weather, two teams who like to put points on the board. The difference is Fla defense and Fla special teams.

GL to all

Post A Comment

Add your response:
Advertisement